SECTION 4. The President, evil President and all civil officers of the united States, shall be gotten rid of from Office ~ above Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or various other high Crimes and also Misdemeanors.

You are watching: How many votes in the senate does it take to remove a president

Annotations

Article II, section 4 provides that officers impeached and also convicted “shall be removed from office”; short article I, section 3, clause 7 provides further that “judgment in instances of impeachment chandelier not prolong further than to removal from office, and disqualification come hold and enjoy any type of office that honor, trust or profit under the joined States.” These restrictions on judgment, both of i beg your pardon relate to volume to hold public office, emphasize the non-penal nature of impeachment, and assist to distinguish American impeachment from the open-ended English practice under which criminal penalties could be imposed.853

The plain language of section 4 seems to call for removal indigenous office ~ above conviction, and also in truth the Senate has actually removed those persons who it has actually convicted. In the 1936 psychological of judge Ritter, the Senate identified that removal is automatic upon conviction, and also does not call for a different vote.854 This practice has continued. Due to the fact that conviction needs a two-thirds vote, this means that removal can take place only together a an outcome of a two-thirds vote. Uneven removal, disqualification from office is a discretionary judgment, and there is no clearly constitutional link to the two-thirds poll on conviction. Back an argument can it is in made the disqualification must nonetheless require a two-thirds vote,855 the Senate has established that disqualification may be accomplished by a simple bulk vote.856


853 See conversation supra the the differences between English and also American impeachment.

854 3 Deschler’sprecedents of The joined States residence Of representatives ch. 14, § 13.9.

855 See Michael J. Gerhardt, The commonwealth Impeachment Process: A Constitutional and Historical evaluation 77–79 (2d ed. 2000).

See more: How Many Emails Did Hillary Delete D 33,000 Emails? Yes And No

856 The Senate enforced disqualification twice, top top Judges Humphreys and also Archbald. In the Humphreys trial the Senate established that the issues of removal and also disqualification space divisible, 3 Hinds’ Precedents the The residence Of to represent § 2397 (1907), and in the Archbald attempt the Senate enforced judgment of disqualification by vote of 39 to 35. 6 Cannon’sprecedents of The house Of to represent § 512 (1936). During the 1936 psychological of judge Ritter, a houses of parliament inquiry as to whether a two-thirds poll or a simple bulk vote is compelled for disqualification to be answered by referral to the simple majority vote in the Archbald trial. 3 Deschler’sprecedents ch. 14, § 13.10. The Senate climate rejected disqualification of referee Ritter by poll of 76–0. 80 Cong. Rec. 5607 (1936).