It's regime for attorneys basic to sue the federal government, however experts say the sharp rise signifies the growing partisan and legal divide v Washington.

You are watching: How many times has trump been sued


*

California Attorney basic Xavier Becerra with brand-new York Attorney basic Letitia James exterior the can be fried Court ~ above Nov. 12, 2019.Al Drago / Bloomberg via Getty pictures file
During president Donald Trump"s four years in office, his administration has sparred in court with state attorneys basic over practically every issue.

Among the topics: the "travel ban"; the Deferred activity for Childhood arrivals program, or DACA; family separations in ~ the U.S.-Mexico border; the "national emergency" statements to build the border wall; international student visas; student loan protections; clean water rules; transgender health care protections; auto emissions; a citizenship concern on the 2020 census; U.S. Postal business operations; and also Obamacare.


If it seems prefer a lot, that is.

A testimonial of litigation versus federal agencies during the Trump management shows the state attorneys general have filed 138 multistate lawsuits due to the fact that he took office, according to data compiled by Paul Nolette, a political scientist in ~ Marquette college in Milwaukee who research studies the office of attorney general.

It"s a sharp rise from Trump"s predecessors, including Barack Obama, whose administration was sued 78 times during his 2 presidential terms, and also George W. Bush, whose management was sued 76 times during his 2 terms.

"The variety of AG lawsuits is off the charts," Nolette said. "These days, they"re really all set to go, together in when a regulation is finalized, within a week, periodically within a work or two, the lawsuit is filed. They"re prepared to run through it."


Any attempt by Donald Trump come deny brand-new York access to a lifesaving #COVID19 vaccine will be met v a lawsuit, plain and also simple. Prevent playing national politics with people"s lives.

— NY AG James (

The vast bulk of the lawsuits were filed by says with democratic attorneys general, a reversal from the greatly Republican attorneys general who sued the Obama administration, the said. Just six lawsuits versus the Trump administration involved a Republican attorney general.


California"s democratic attorney general, Xavier Becerra, has been part of the most multistate lawsuits, follow to Nolette"s data.


*

July: California AG on trump card administration's international student visa policy

July 10, 202002:12
Massachusetts Attorney basic Maura Healey, a Democrat, whose state has been a plaintiff in dozens of cases versus the trumped administration, claimed the White House adopted extreme positions that in her see flouted laws and also required regular action.

"We had actually to be there under this administration as the president and also his enablers involved in conduct that was illegal and also unconstitutional and did harm to occupants of ours state," claimed Healey, a co-chair that the democratic Attorneys general Association, which support the autonomous attorneys general of 24 states and also Washington, D.C.


Republican attorneys general represent 26 states. Some have actually accused autonomous attorneys general of selecting legal debates on the basis of political expediency.

"The truth that the Democrats have filed over twice as plenty of lawsuits versus Trump in just 4 years 보다 the republic filed versus Obama end eight years provides it clear the Democrats space using the courts to beat politics," said Kelly Laco, nationwide press secretary for the Republican Attorneys basic Association, which seeks to get more Republicans chosen to the position.

During the trump administration, the eco-friendly Protection company has been sued the many of any kind of federal agency — 47 times — and also it to be a frequent target during previous administrations, as well.

These cook legal officers have actually a selection of strength at your disposal and mandates to protect their states" rights, enforce your laws and also defend consumers, i m sorry helps describe why they have actually clashed so regularly legally and also politically through the trump administration, experts say.


"The AGs have really come into their own," Nolette said. "They"re acquisition full advantage of your institutional power. And since AGs have actually a an excellent deal that independence, they have the right to do so without gift tied by the branch or state legislators, which method they have the right to prioritize what lock want."

One the the earliest multistate lawsuits filed throughout the Trump administration included democratic attorneys general of 16 states and the district of Columbia who asked the fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Virginia, to uphold a ruling that clogged a significant part that the so-called travel ban, which sought to suspend immigration into the U.S. Indigenous some mainly Muslim countries.

The instance was tied increase in the courts, and also the attorneys general were supported by federal rulings invalidating or scaling earlier versions that the ban. Ultimately, the concern reached the can be fried Court, i beg your pardon upheld the travel restriction in a 5-4 ruling praised through Trump.


Trump claimed in a explain at the time that it to be a "tremendous victory" and also that "this judgment is also a minute of extensive vindication."


But follow to Nolette, trump card hasn"t frequently succeeded in the courts, and also state attorneys general have won 79 percent of their lawsuits, with around 60 much more still undecided.


Nolette said the attorneys basic have the advantage in multistate suits that deciding which district court to paper in and also potentially acquire the most favorable judgment from a judge, a process known together "forum shopping."

For instance, democratic attorneys general might seek to file suits in the districts of northern California and also Southern new York, whereas during the Obama administration, their Republican counterparts often chose Texas, Nolette said.

Trump and his Republican allies, meanwhile, have actually overhauled the federal judiciary in ~ a brisk pace by installing more than 150 ar judges end the past 4 years to fill post-Obama vacancies, as well as ensuring that the can be fried Court tilted much more conservatively.


While Trump continues to challenge the outcomes of his run for re-election against Democrat Joe Biden, the projected winner, observers expect outstanding lawsuits against the Trump management to it is in temporarily halted, because President-elect Biden has promised come unwind numerous of Trump"s policies.

New York Attorney general Letitia James, a Democrat, said last month the her office was currently preparing a perform of legit actions to aid Biden"s team.

Related


Ultimately, pending lawsuits filed by autonomous attorneys general against the Trump administration could be dismissed should the Biden administration readjust policies in your favor.

But new lawsuits room expected to it is in filed by Republican attorneys general trying to avoid Democrats indigenous reversing those policies. Last week, the Republican Attorneys general Association tapped Attorneys general Chris Carr the Georgia, Eric Schmitt of Missouri and Steve Marshall the Alabama for management roles in 2021.


"The Republican attorneys basic are preparing to be first on the prior lines versus a feasible Biden-Harris administration in stimulate to safeguard the rule of law and also protect constitution freedoms because that future generations," Laco said.

Greg Zoeller, a Republican who was Indiana"s attorney general from 2009 come 2017, said the "dysfunction of the legislative branch" was a huge reason Obama thrust through executive, management orders and administrative rules of his own, i beg your pardon alarmed Republican attorneys general.

"His frustration with a deadlocked Congress to be understandable, but it raised apparent constitutional questions," Zoeller said.

While Zoeller join multistate lawsuits versus the Obama administration, he additionally sidestepped legal actions seek by Mike Pence, then the governor of Indiana, once he didn"t think a difficulty could be successful in court.

See more: How Many Troops Are Going To The Border Was ‘Unwarranted,’ Biden Said


"There was likewise criticism the these legal obstacles were political and also based on plan differences," Zoeller said. "My an answer to media and to my Democrat AG partner was the they could rue the day once a Republican president would wield executive government using comparable logic. The past four years room a testimony to what ns warned of in ~ the time."

James Tierney, a autonomous former attorney basic of Maine who is now a lecturer at Harvard law School, said Trump has largely himself to blame for the flurry that lawsuits ~ he provided executive orders and also other directives to push his agenda, frequently bypassing Congress and also administrative laws.

"Depending on what president Biden go — and more importantly, how he does that — GOP AGs have the right to be supposed to sue," Tierney said. "How often and to what level of success will count on what chairman Biden in reality does."