WASHINGTON — The Senate narrowly defeated a bill at an early stage Friday that would certainly have repealed limited portions the Obamacare as Republican Sen. Man McCain cast the deciding vote against the plan.

You are watching: How many senate votes are needed to repeal obamacare

Senators poll 49-51 because that the bill, falling two votes brief of the 51 votes necessary to happen the legislation. In addition to McCain, the Republicans who voted versus the invoice were Sens. Susan Collins that Maine and also Lisa Murkowski the Alaska.

The poll was a major blow to GOP Senate leaders. House and Senate republicans campaigned top top a promise to repeal and also replace the Affordable care Act, but they have actually struggled to reach agreement on how to execute that.

Senate majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., Vice president Pence and also other GOP leaders could be checked out lobbying McCain and Murkowski ~ above the Senate floor before the vote. Yet it was clear once Democrats hugged McCain that the bill would certainly fail.

McConnell said at about 2 a.m. That it to be "time to move on" rather than make the efforts again to pass a GOP bill. He said he desires to hear principles from Democrats about what come do next on health and wellness care.

"What us tried to achieve for the American people was the appropriate thing because that the country," McConnell, who was plainly shaken, claimed after the vote. "And our just regret is that us didn"t accomplish what we had actually hoped to accomplish. Ns think the American people are walking to regret that us couldn"t discover a better way forward."

Senate minority Leader lining Schumer, D-N.Y., stated Democrats are eager to work with republicans to enhance Obamacare.

"We space not celebrating," Schumer said. "We space relieved ... No for ourselves, yet for the American people."


Schumer"s voice broke as the praised McCain for his vessel in spreading the deciding vote. The Arizona councilor learned last week that he has a mind tumor yet returned come Capitol Hill this week therefore he might vote on health and wellness care. That voted Tuesday to enable the Senate to debate the GOP bills, however he do no promises to support them.

“From the beginning, ns have thought that Obamacare have to be repealed and also replaced v a systems that boosts competition, lowers costs, and improves treatment for the American people. The so-called ‘skinny repeal’ amendment the Senate voted on this particular day would not attain those goals," McCain claimed in a statement after ~ the vote.

President trump tweeted that the three Republicans and 48 democrats "let the American civilization down." 

"As I claimed from the beginning, watch ObamaCare implode, then deal. Watch!" trumped tweeted.

The non-partisan Congressional budget plan Office claimed the beat bill, dubbed the Health care Freedom Act, would have actually resulted in 16 million under Americans with medical coverage by 2026. It additionally would have increased premiums by about 20% for human being buying their insurance in the individual marketplace every year between 2018 and also 2026.

McConnell claimed the bill would have actually ended the mandates that individuals buy wellness insurance and that larger employers offer affordable coverage to your workers. He said it likewise would have actually provided more versatility to states in giving medical treatment to low-income americans and repealed the medical maker tax for three years while raising the amount of money that civilization could add to health Savings Accounts.

The provision to defund Planned Parenthood drew opposition native Collins and Murkowski.

"The American people have experienced under Obamacare for also long," McConnell claimed in a decided on the Senate floor Thursday night. "It’s time to end the failed condition quo. It’s time to send law to the president the will lastly move ours country beyond the failure of Obamacare. Happen this law will allow us to occupational with our partner in the house toward a final bill that have the right to go come the president, repeal Obamacare, and undo that damage."

The American medical Association automatically denounced the bill.

"The so-called "skinny" invoice is a toxic prescription that would make matters worse," claimed AMA president David Barbe. "Eliminating the individual mandate will result in adverse selection, triggering greater premiums and further destabilizing the individual market. The declared goal to be to advance policies to reduced premiums, yet the "skinny" bill would carry out the precise opposite, harming patients throughout the country."

McCain and also Sens. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C. And Ron Johnson, R-Wis., announced previously in the evening the they would certainly not support a "skinny repeal" bill unless they had a guarantee the residence would actually start negotiations and also not simply pass the Senate bill and send the to chairman Trump.

House speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., do the efforts to carry out that assurance by saying the house would be "willing" to walk to conference if that was what was compelled to relocate a invoice forward. That won end Graham and also Johnson, but McCain claimed it didn"t walk far sufficient in assuring him that the house wouldn"t vote on the thin repeal at part point.

See more: A Species Revived: How Many Nipples Do Pandas Have ? Panda Facts I

"The Speaker"s statement the the house would be ‘willing’ to walk to conference does no ease my issue that this shell of a bill could be bring away up and also passed at any type of time," McCain said.

Friday"s vote was the third — and most terrible — loss this week because that Republican leaders. The Senate rubbish a leadership plan to replace Obamacare on Tuesday night 43-57, with nine republicans voting against it. And on Wednesday, a clean repeal of the health care law — with a two-year hold-up to come up v a replacement — failure 45-55.