“Sanctuary cities” is actually a misnomer. While countless Americans believe that it describes a city that doesn’t prosecute immigrants, so-called “sanctuary cities” actually describe something far an ext specific.

You are watching: How many sanctuary cities in the united states

There’s no single an interpretation of what is a sanctuary city, however generally speaking, that a city (or a county, or a state) that boundaries its cooperation with federal immigration enforcement agents in bespeak to safeguard low-priority immigrant from deportation, when still turning over those who have committed severe crimes. This is why we favor the term “safe cities”.

Table the Contents

Sanctuary cities: what is a sanctuary city?The case of AlexWhy are sanctuary cities important?Sanctuary cities space saferPolice departments support sanctuary policiesWhat go Trump want through sanctuary cities?Sanctuary cities and states’ rightsThe background of the Trump administration and sanctuary citiesSessions’ sue on californiaJeff Sessions’ room of justice letterTrump’s executive order trying to defund sanctuary urban — and the mountain Francisco ruling versus him

Sanctuary cities: what is a sanctuary city?

Sanctuary cities come into play when an undocumented immigrant come into contact with the police. A very common event of this wake up on the road – who is speeding, has a damaged taillight, or has actually a broken license plate light, and also is traction over. If a human is undocumented, opportunities are they perform not have actually a precious driver’s patent – only twelve states and also the ar of Columbia permit immigrants come legally drive. Immigrants still have to acquire to work and also school somehow – but being found without a valid driver’s license can acquire an separation, personal, instance arrested.

Other reasons immigrants (just prefer native-born Americans) come into call with the police encompass an immigrant calling the police come their house (for instance in the case of a domestic dispute), a car accident, medicine usage, police checkpoints, so forth.

Once one immigrant is arrested, their info gets put into a commonwealth database the is mutual with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). ICE have the right to then problem a hold, likewise called a detainer, asking the police to hold that human in custody until ICE can come choose that human up for immigrant detention and eventual deportation.

Here’s whereby we obtain to important legal allude #1: being undocumented is no a crime. That a civil violation. Undocumented immigrants have rights under the U.S. Constitution. and also according to due process, the police can not detain anyone that hasn’t at the very least been doubt of a crime. If a police officer encounters someone walking under the street who turns out to it is in undocumented, they cannot arrest the person due to the fact that that person has not cursed a crime (ICE, however, can). Similarly, if the police arrest who undocumented – because that example, someone suspected the committing a crime, that is climate cleared, they must let that person go.

Important legal allude #2: holding an immigrant previous the point when they have to be released, simply so the ICE can pick lock up, is unconstitutional. Multiple courts have said so, and immigrants can sue the police because that unlawful holding.

Here us get earlier to the suggest of sanctuary cities: in a sanctuary city, the police will release one arrested immigrant after ~ he’s to be cleared the charges, post bail, or completed jail time for every little thing he to be arrested for. A non-sanctuary city will host that human being until ICE deserve to come choose them increase – even though that extra holding is no constitutional.

Keep in psychic that all of the above only uses if the undocumented person has actually not committed any type of serious crimes. If castle have, the police have the right to keep castle in jail by filing charges. Or ice cream can current the police with a warrant or various other order native a judge, i beg your pardon will result in a organize until ICE deserve to come by.

Read more at the Washington Post: exactly how sanctuary urban work, and also how Trump’s executive, management order might influence them

The case of Alex

Here’s a nice real-life example of how this works: let’s take it “Alex”, someone who is in the us without documents (and who is not a Dreamer). One day, Alex it s okay pulled end the police due to the fact that his taillight is broken. The police find out the he has no driver’s license. They take it Alex and also put the in prison overnight because of the driver’s license infraction; otherwise Alex has actually no criminal document whatsoever. If Alex is in jail, the police place his info into the federal database mutual with ICE, and ICE puts a organize / detainer ~ above him.

Remember: Alex is in jail for a driver’s patent infraction. He has not committed any type of other crimes. The truth that that is an undocumented immigrant is no a crime. The police deserve to hold him because that what he’s excellent — journey without a license. But holding him previous the time as soon as he must be released, simply so that immigrant agents can come choose him up, is unconstitutional.

If Alex doesn’t live in a so-called “sanctuary city”, the police can hold him for days or much longer until immigration agents pick him up, which could put Alex ~ above the route to deportation even though he’s done nothing as well as drive there is no a license. Even though this is right now what plenty of cities and counties carry out – even though this is what the Trump administration wants cities and counties to perform – the illegal due to the fact that it robs immigrants choose Alex of due process.

If Alex does live in a sanctuary city, the police would identify that Alex has actually not committed any serious crimes and also release that (in this example) ~ his one night in jail. That’s what they’re supposed to do. It is why some also suggest that we speak to sanctuary urban “constitutional cities”.

Why are sanctuary urban important?

Sanctuary cities space safer

In a sentence, sanctuary urban make everyone safer. This is because:

The police can emphasis on walking after severe criminals, rather than arresting or detaining immigrants simply for gift undocumentedCities, communities, and law enforcement desire undocumented immigrant to to trust the police. In order because that the police to be most effective at your jobs, they require to be able to work v immigrants that report crimes, give tips, or testify as witnesses. In stimulate for immigrants to to trust the police, they need to understand that an communication with legislation enforcement won’t lead to their deportation.

Research backs this up; one analysis has presented that sanctuary cities check out 15% much less crime than non-sanctuary cities. An additional found the two-thirds of the urban that had the highest jumps in murder prices in 2016 were not sanctuary cities – in fact, they space the opposite, normally eager to organize immigrants for ice pick-up and also detention.

In contrast, scary points can happen when immigrants become afraid of the police. In Houston, the police chief provided that the number of Hispanics reporting rape is under 42.8% from last year, and the number reporting various other violent crimes has actually dropped 13%. This is during a year as soon as crimes report by non-Hispanics increased. Immigrants in California additionally aren’t report sex crimes, while fear of deportation caused women in Colorado come drop domestic abuse instances in i beg your pardon they to be witnesses.

Police departments assistance sanctuary policies

That’s why so numerous law enforcement policemans support sanctuary city policies. That includes the Fraternal bespeak of Police, a membership organization which endorsed Donald trumped in the 2016 election however has since told him to earlier off the idea the punishing cities or your police departments for immigrant-friendly sanctuary policies.

Here are some op-eds from law enforcement officers about why they assistance sanctuary policies. This is just a small sampling of the dozens of regulation enforcement officials that have spoken out in favor of sanctuary cities:

What does Trump want through sanctuary cities?

The trumped Administration, and especially Attorney basic Jeff Sessions, has actually repeatedly tried to target sanctuary cities. They gain in the means of the Administration’s massive deportation efforts, and Sessions has repeatedly intimidated to defund them. However the law below is on the cities’ side, partly as result of a conservative pet cause: states’ rights.

Sanctuary cities and also states’ rights

It’s ironic and also hypocritical because that Republican legislator to need the sanctuary cities and counties handle immigrants the way Trump and Sessions desire cities and also counties to take care of them, because conservatives are an alleged to support protecting local federal government from commonwealth intrusion. Luckily, there room pretty solid supreme Court rulings – some written by conservative justices — that safeguard states native the trump card Administration’s needs over sanctuary policies. According to the courts:

The federal federal government cannot place conditions on sponsor to states and also localities uneven the conditions are “unambiguously” proclaimed in the lawThe federal government cannot “commandeer” state and local public representative to aid them obtrude federal regulation (for example, the federal government forcing the police to organize immigrants for ice cream agents)The federal federal government cannot coerce says or localities into action with a gaue won “gun to the head”

The background of the Trump administration and sanctuary cities

Even despite the Trump management is dorn on sanctuary cities, it has actually repeatedly tried to strike them — and also immigrant communities.

Sessions’ lawsuit versus California

In march 2018, Sessions announced that he was filing a lawsuit versus California and also state plans which he deemed too immigrant friendly. Except, as note Joseph Stern in ~ Slate wrote:

Sessions didn’t have the guts to go after California’s primary sanctuary law due to the fact that he would certainly lose. Instead, he has targeted three secondary policies that make up a small section of the state’s more comprehensive immigration regime. Also if Sessions prospered in overturning all three laws, California would continue to be a sanctuary state. Yet he more than likely won’t success in killing any of them. Probably this lawsuit is just an additional desperate effort to win back President Donald Trump’s affections.

Sessions is targeting 1) a preeminence that bars California regulation enforcement agencies from sharing information around undocumented immigrants, 2) a state law that protects immigrant from rectal raids, and also 3) one act permitting the California attorney general to check immigration detention facilities within the state. Stern provided that all three contents of Sessions’ lawsuit initiative are likely doomed, saying:

Sessions, a self-proclaimed defender of states’ rights, is search to undermine states’ ability to command their own affairs. The is intruding top top California’s police powers and undermining its defense of civil rights due to the fact that he dislikes the state’s laws. Sessions may wish the every state would certainly accede to his policy agenda. But he can’t use the structure to make them obey his commands.

Recently, the room of homeland Security and Acting ice Director thomas Homan have threatened local elected officials themselves because that actions they’ve taken and also actions your jurisdictions have actually taken to safeguard immigrants. As the ACLU wrote, these threats room “lawless and also baseless”. Moreover:

The idea of this prosecutions is insidious. In ~ bottom, the administration’s complaint is the localities room adopting policies with which the disagrees. This idea the locking up elected officials for their political speech, beliefs, and votes is contradictory to the first Amendment and also the autonomous principles on i m sorry our country was founded. Even the suggestion is dangerous and also reprehensible.

Sessions’ department of justice letters

In April 2017, Sessions sent out a letter to nine jurisdictions (one state, four cities, and four counties), telling them to acquire their sanctuary policies right v the trump card Administration, or else lose part of a $265 million provide intended to aid police and prosecutors.

Except the threat in Sessions’ letter was ignorant of exactly how immigration regulation works. What Sessions’ letter want the jurisdictions to do was follow a 1996 state that states a city/county/state cannot prevent an main from talk to the feds around the immigration status of an individual. Virtually every city and county in the nation is in compliance v this requirement, including those the the Trump administration considers to be sanctuary cities. That part of the law is not even in conflict – yet Sessions because that some factor saw right to put jurisdictions on notification over it.

What Sessions (and Trump) ultimately want, the course, is for cities and counties to organize undocumented immigrant for ice pickup and also detention. But as described above, once an immigrant has actually committed no crime, holding them for ice cream is not constant with current law, and cities and counties have the right to be held liable because that violating immigrants’ rights. Sessions was unable to define away this incoherence throughout a meeting with the mayors that the urban he targeted, and also the mayors ultimately left confused. Top top a number of immigration issues, “we hear really different message from (Homeland Security), DOJ and likewise the White House,” stated Jorge Elorza, the market of Providence, RI. “Just provide us clarity and also please have actually one, clear plan so we have the right to know whereby we stand.”

In addition, for all of around two weeks, the Trump administration published a weekly report that cities and also counties that, in that opinion, operated illegal sanctuary policies. Except, as defined above, urban that don’t organize immigrants because that ICE space operating in accordance v the law, while cities that do hold immigrants for ICE room behaving unconstitutionally – even though this is the contrary of what the Trump administration wants to it is in true. A number of cities and counties clapped back versus the Trump management for trying to name and shame them even though they to be just following the law, forcing the administration to apologize come a variety of them and – after just a pair of mainly – prevent publishing the reports altogether.

Trump’s executive, management order trying come defund sanctuary cities

In January 2017, trump card signed an executive, management order calling on sanctuary urban to comply with federal immigration regulation or else have federal capital pulled. But in April, a san Francisco judge blocked the order, saying the the president had actually overstepped his powers by trying to tie billions in federal funding to immigration enforcement, and that just Congress can place such conditions on spending. The judge also detailed that federal funding conditions have to be tied to the policy in inquiry – for example, real estate funds can not be conditional on immigrant laws.

See more: How Many Ounces In Wendy’S Large Drink, Https://Www

Just as the referee striking under Trump’s Muslim ban did, the mountain Francisco judge provided the words of the Trump administration against itself, to prove that the intent behind Trump’s executive, management order to be something other than what the government’s lawyers declared in court. Once more, the big mouths behind Trump and his administration are help to defeat their own policies.