Left-leaning movie critics of U.S. President Donald trumped rejected his insurance claims to overseeing unprecedented financial growth in beforehand 2020. That was right?

Published19 February 2020

Share on facebookshare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare ~ above RedditShare via Email

Earlier, the left-leaning autonomous Coalition group posted a link to a Yahoo! News post with the title “Trump’s an initial 3 Years created 1.5 Million Fewer jobs Than Obama’s critical 3,” including “FACT: new figures from Trump’s own Department of Labor show that 6.6 million new jobs were developed in the very first 36 month of Trump’s tenure, contrasted with 8.1 million in the last 36 months of Obama’s ― a decline of 19% under Trump.”

That article was chin a republication of a Feb. 10 report released by HuffPost, which read as follows:

“As chairman Donald Trump take away the phase at his reelection rally right here Monday and boasts of his economic record, there is one statistic the is likely to omit: He developed 1.5 million fewer jobs in his very first three year in office than predecessor Barack Obama go in his final three. Recently revised numbers from Trump’s very own Department the Labor display that 6.6 million brand-new jobs were created in the first 36 months of Trump’s tenure, compared with 8.1 million in the final 36 months of Obama’s ― a decrease of 19% under Trump, follow to a HuffPost analysis.”

How to Measure tasks Growth

The HuffPost write-up didn’t point out the exact metric it offered in bespeak to arrive at those numbers, however the standard figure used come gauge jobs growth in the United states is total, seasonally adjusted non-farm payroll employment, i beg your pardon is released every month as part of the bureau of job Statistics (BLS) facility survey, in i m sorry BLS collection data from a sample of around 145,000 businesses and also government organ throughout the country.

You are watching: How many jobs has obama created

When a news headline claims that, for example, the economic situation “added 225,000 work in January,” that’s commonly a referral to seasonally changed non-farm payroll employment and also it way there to be 225,000 an ext jobs in the United states in January 2020, than there were in December 2019. 

Once a year, the BLS revises its employed data after consulting more official figures accumulated from each state’s unemployment insurance agency. This “benchmark” revision procedure enhances the accuracy of tasks figures and also typically outcomes in retreat adjustments come employment statistics indigenous every month over the coming before 10 years. 

That’s what taken place on Feb. 7, once the BLS released both the preliminary employment figures for January and revised jobs numbers native 2010 through 2019. Those revisions meant that jobs growth in 2018 turned the end to it is in slower 보다 was initially recorded, prompting Slate to report that:

“On Friday, the office of labor Statistics exit its latest batch of employed numbers, together with its yearly benchmark revisions adjusting its approximates from front months. Before, the government believed that the U.S. Had added 223,000 tasks per month in 2018, the year that the GOP’s taxes cuts and new, greater spending levels take it effect. It has now lowered that estimate to 193,000 per month, a far-reaching drop.”

For its part, MSNBC composed that:

The revisions for 2019 showed that the economic situation generated virtually 2.1 million work last year, i m sorry is a pretty good number. The trouble, however, is the job totals from critical year were under from the year before, and also were actually the lowest because 2011. Or put another way, while Trump invested the year boasting the the U.S. Job sector was the strongest it’s ever before been, 2019 saw job growth slow to an eight-year low.

What’s more, the ideal year for jobs during Trump’s presidency — 2.31 million in 2018 — stops working to reach the job expansion in any of the three final years of Barack Obama’s presidency. That adds a degree of irony come his rhetorical record: trumped ran because that president in 2015 and 2016, telling the country that the economic situation was horrible and also he’d make it vastly better. But yearly job growth totals from both 2015 and also 2016 were much better than any year of the Republican’s tenure, at least so far.

Taking this one step further, Trump has now remained in office because that 36 full months — February 2017 v January 2020 — and in the time, the economy has produced 6.56 million jobs. In the 36 months coming before Trump’s presidency — February 2014 come January 2017 — the economy created 8.08 million jobs.

The Numbers

Before we present the numbers at the heart of this reality check, it must be detailed that together a rule, political leaders overstate their affect over the economic situation when signs are healthy, and also downplay their influence when things room bad. Together Neil Irwin created for The brand-new York Times, prior to Trump’s inauguration in January 2017:

“The truth is the presidents have much less manage over the economy than you could imagine. Presidential financial records are very dependent top top the dumb luck of whereby the country is in the financial cycle. And the White House has actually no control over the demographic and technical forces that influence the economy. Even in locations where the president yes, really does have actually power to form the economic climate — appointing commonwealth Reserve governors, steering fiscal and also regulatory policy, responding to crises and external shocks — the relationship between presidential action and financial outcome is frequently uncertain and also hard come prove.”

However, trump himself has repeatedly insisted on tying positive economic indicators choose employment growth to his very own presidency. So even if we might dispute the premise the presidents should receive unqualified praise or blame once the economy grows or tanks, it’s precious checking the number involved. After ~ all, if trumped proposes the he is to be thanked for employment growth, his own logic dictates that he need to be blamed if that rate of expansion is slow down.

In order come measure and compare tasks growth during Obama’s last three years in office and jobs growth during Trump’s an initial three, we derived a data collection containing 10 years’ precious of monthly non-farm payroll employed staff figures, i m sorry BLS confirmed for audioeditorfree.com was the most reliable and up-to-date data collection available, and took right into account the February 2020 benchmark revisions. The spreadsheet can be download here, and also the table is displayed below:

It’s important to note that the monthly employment figures for December 2019 and also January 2020 room both quiet preliminary. The January 2020 number will it is in revised in March, and also all the monthly figures presented in the table space liable to be more revised in 2021, once BLS conducts its annual benchmark revisions again. 

There are several potential ways to to compare jobs expansion under Obama and Trump, depending on where you ar the transition between the 2 administrations. Because Trump to be inaugurated on Jan. 20, 2017, there is a case for “starting the clock” in January 2017, but also for beginning it in February 2017, since that to be his first full month in office. If the function of the to compare is to gauge the feasible influence the a presidency on employment trends, one could also measure tasks growth starting in November 2016, since that’s once Trump was actually elected, or in December 2016, due to the fact that that was the an initial full month that what could be explained as the “Trump era.”

Finally, if one wished come use just the many reliable figures available, and also exclude the preliminary data indigenous December 2019 and January 2020, one could track jobs development for simply the very first 34 month of Trump’s presidency (from February 2017 come November 2019), and compare the to the last 34 month of Obama’s tenure (from April 2014 come January 2017).

The following table takes right into account all five methods. Each of castle demonstrates the the final three year of Obama’s presidency saw considerably superior jobs development than the very first three year of Trump’s presidency.


As the table shows, Obama’s last three years in office saw significantly greater jobs development than Trump’s fist three years did, no matter where the change between presidencies is placed. Across the an initial four various methods, the void averages out at around 1.5 million tasks — meaning the insurance claim at the center of this fact inspect was accurate.

Employment has actually grown during the first three year of Trump’s presidency, however at a substantially slower price than the did towards the end of Obama’s tenure — across the very first four techniques used here, jobs growth under Trump has averaged out at roughly 19% slower than the rate of expansion experienced during his predecessor’s final three years in office.

When we exclude the two months the preliminary data (December 2019 and also January 2020) and also compare block of 34 months every (as opposed to block of 36 months), the jobs growth gap is normally slightly smaller sized (because the time durations in question are contempt shorter), but the space in the rate of development is quiet significant, v Trump’s presidency seeing employment prosper 18.2% more slowly 보다 it did throughout the last 34 month of Obama’s time in office.

Date, S.V. “Trump’s an initial 3 Years produced 1.5 Million Fewer work Than Obama’s critical 3.” Yahoo! News. 10 February 2020.

Date, S.V. “Trump’s very first 3 Years produced 1.5 Million Fewer jobs Than Obama’s last 3.” HuffPost. 10 February 2020.

U.S. Bureau of labor Statistics. “Economic News relax — the employed staff Situation, January 2020.” 7 February 2020.

Benen, Steve. “The Nagging Detail around Job development Trump more than likely Won’t Like.” MSNBC. 7 February 2020.

Irwin, Neil. “Presidents have actually Less strength Over the economic climate Than You could Think.” The brand-new York Times. 17 January 2017.

See more: How Many Claps In Friends Theme Song Got Its Iconic Claps, Remember The Iconic Claps In Friends Theme Song

Boak, Josh; Miller, Zeke. “Trump insurance claims Credit because that Economy, work in new York Speech.” The associated Press. 12 November 2019.