The claim: Trump banned welfare for some immigrants, i beg your pardon will conserve $57.4 billion a year

President Donald Trump"s agenda has fueled a stream of immigration-related misinformation. 

A claim that Trump banned welfare because that immigrants in the U.S. Illegally, which will conserve $57.4 billion every year, has circulated ~ above Facebook and also resurfaced in late May. But this claim is false because that a pair of reasons.

You are watching: How many immigrants are on welfare

First, trumped didn’t half welfare for immigrant in the U.S. Illegally. Undocumented immigrants have actually been ineligible for many federal programs due to the fact that before Trump took office. 

Second, the “$57.4 billion” figure comes from a 2017 research that measure up the economic price of basic public services at the state and also local level of immigrant who pertained to the country both legally and also illegally and also their children. Therefore this measurement includes all immigrants, not just those below illegally, together the Facebook write-up claims. Researchers attributed most of the $57.4 exchange rate to education, PolitiFact reported.

USA now contacted the claimant yet did not receive a response.

Fact check:Trump doesn’t outperform various other presidents regardless of 2 month of solid job gains


Examining "$57.4 billion" 

The national Academies published in 2017 a 618-page report by the Committee of national Statistics that details the economic influence of immigration in the joined States.

The report averaged data from 2011-13 and also concluded that first-generation immigrant (foreign-born residents) and also their dependents (children) cost state and local governments $57.4 billion, with most that the expense walking to education. 

But researchers relied on data indigenous the Census Bureau’s Current population Survey, which according to the professor who chaired the dashboard of researchers, barred castle from distinguishing between types of immigration, PolitiFact reported. So your estimate contains immigrants who pertained to the nation legally and also illegally. That"s not what the facebook user claimed.


The report noted “the second and third-plus generation people (and your children) develop benefits the $30.5 billion and also $223.8 billion. … keep in mind that the surplus profits raised amount come $197 billion, which amounts to the surplus throughout all 50 states. ... By the second generation, immigrants space a net victory for the says as a whole, provided that they have fewer youngsters on typical than first generation units and also are contributing in revenues an ext than they cost in expenditures.”


Some immigrants have actually been ineligible for many social services

Congress has long limited immigrants’ accessibility to windy benefits. A federal legislation in 1882 developed that immigration officials have to deny entry to any type of person most likely to become a "public charge."

That mindset prevails.

“Undocumented immigrants, consisting of DACA (Deferred action for Childhood Arrivals) holders, space ineligible to receive many federal windy benefits, consisting of means-tested services such as Supplemental Nutrition aid Program (SNAP, sometimes referred to together food stamps), continuous Medicaid, Supplemental Security revenue (SSI), and also Temporary assistance for Needy families (TANF)," the nationwide Immigrant Forum, a nonprofit that advocates for immigrant reform, describes on the website. "Undocumented immigrants space ineligible for health treatment subsidies under the Affordable care Act (ACA).”


Immigrants in the U.S. Illegally deserve to be standard for some benefits “that space deemed important to protect life or guarantee safety and security in dire situations.” These incorporate emergency Medicaid, emergency room treatment and health treatment programs under the one-of-a-kind Supplemental Nutrition program for Women, Infants and Children.

Some states offer solutions to immigrant — most of which room funded by the state — regardless of immigration status. Qualifications vary by state.

Despite restrictions of public benefits to immigrants, research study confirms immigrants contribute much more in taxes than the cost of the services they receive. 

Immigrants in the U.S. Illegally contribute $11.6 billion every year in state and also local count for benefits they likely will not receive, according to a 2016 report by academy on Taxation and Economic Policy, a left-leaning think tank. And also according come a 2013 society Security administration report, unauthorized immigrant paid $13 billion in payroll taxes even though “only around $1 billion in advantage payments throughout 2010 are attributable come unauthorized work.”

Trump’s constraints on immigration

When PolitiFact reported on this insurance claim earlier in the year, it indicated that society media users might have puzzled Trump “banning welfare” for immigrants that arrived below illegally through the announcement of a brand-new interpretation of that legislation passed more than 100 years ago. 

Trump in august 2019 increased the decision-making process of the "public charge" law. Immigrant whom officials thought about to it is in a publicly charge, or load on society, might be understood ineligible because that residency. 

Before Trump’s interpretation, a “public charge” meant a human who to be “primarily dependent” on government assistance. However Trump’s move increased this definition, which specialists predict will prevent numerous thousands of immigrant who concerned the U.S. From living here permanently. 

Our ruling: False

President Donald trump card did not ban welfare for immigrants in the U.S. Illegally. Those who involved the nation illegally have long been barred native the bulk of government services. And also although that unclear where the claimant uncovered the number $57.4 billion, a research out the the nationwide Academy of sciences cited that number together the average cost of every immigrants, not just undocumented, in ~ the state and local, no federal, level. We, therefore, rate this insurance claim as FALSE since it is not sustained by our research.

See more: How Long Does A Hot Dog Take To Boil Hot Dogs, How To Boil Hot Dogs: Learn In 5 Easy Steps


Our fact-check sources:

National immigration Forum, “Fact Sheet: Immigrants and Public Benefits,” Aug. 21, 2018

Thank friend for sustaining our journalism. You can subscribe to our publish edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.