One of the more contentious concerns in the 1996 welfare reform controversy was whether the federal federal government should carry out welfare services to non-citizens who room legal residents of the unified States. The periodically bitter debate revealed a basic divide in exactly how advocates, analysts, and also policymakers think about welfare because that non-citizens. Top top the one hand, those who support welfare benefits for non-citizens suggest out that at the moment of the 1996 reforms, legitimate non-citizens enjoyed accessibility to a wide selection of welfare benefits. This access was based on the principle that non-citizens come to America to get involved in the full range of American social, economic, and also political life and also that, through modest exceptions, they have to be treated like other Americans. The kids of non-citizens, the vast bulk of whom space American citizens, are particularly deserving of the security net detailed by welfare programs. Supporters believe that to refuse non-citizens and also their youngsters welfare services is to leave them outside the protective sphere of social welfare guaranteed to the disabled and destitute by federal and state government policy. Moreover, like various other Americans, non-citizens pay taxes, and unlike non-citizens in plenty of other countries, can be drafted in time of war.

You are watching: How many illegal immigrants are receiving welfare

By contrast, those who oppose benefits for non-citizens argue the restricting their access to welfare has been a rule of American residential policy since colonial times. The commonwealth law, established in 1882 and strengthened in the early on twentieth century, to be that immigration officials should refuse entrance to any non-citizen who appeared likely to end up being a “public charge” and should deport those who did, although really deportations of publicly charges have been rare. Those supporting the 1996 revolutionary also allude out that, both in statutory law and also in the mental of American citizens together revealed in polls, welfare for non-citizens has constantly been suspect. The congressional prohibitions from the so late nineteenth century have already been mentioned, but more recent constraints are likewise notable. Specifics in 1993 the Democrati-cally controlled Congress extended from 3 to five years the period that immigrant entering the country had come wait before they can qualify because that the Supplemental Security revenue (SSI) program. Thus, the principle the non-citizens perform not deserve to benefits top top the same basis as citizens has long to be established and also maintained by the Congress. Finally, those in favor of advantage cuts for non-citizens have been strongly urged to conserve taxpayer dollars and also balance the budget

In 1996, those who supported lessened welfare because that non-citizens, mainly Republicans, had actually the upper hand in both residences of Congress. The revolutionary they enacted to be sweeping in both your intent and effect. Together the 2002 reauthorization dispute begins, those protest to the 1996 reforms and also those in donate of them are preparing for one more lively conflict on both the fundamental principles and the details provisions that federal legislation on welfare for non-citizens. There is a good chance the Congress will certainly enact some benefit expansions.

Overview that 1996 Provisions

The 1996 reforms readjusted almost every facet of non-citizen eligibility because that welfare benefits. Return the provisions are exceedingly complex, a rough general principle provides advantageous guidance. V some exceptions, non-citizens beginning the United claims after august 22, 1996, the day of it spreads widespread of the welfare revolutionary legislation, room not standard for most welfare benefits, including Temporary aid for Needy households (TANF), SSI, Medicaid, and the State Children’s wellness Insurance routine (SCHIP), till they have been in the U.S. For at least 5 years. Maintaining this basic principle in mind, a more thorough testimonial of the 1996 provisions discover both your complexity and also breadth.


In identify welfare eligibility because that non-citizens, two broad criteria are taken right into account. The many general screen is the ide of “qualified” and “not qualified” alien. Generally, default aliens room non-citizens who have been permitted to reside permanently in the unified States. They encompass legal permanent residents (LPRs), refugees, asylees, Cuban/Haitian entrants, and also a couple of other categories. Qualified immigrants may be eligible because that federal and state advantage programs that aim to assist families with restricted income and also resources. Not qualified aliens (mostly illegal and also temporary immigrants), by contrast, are ineligible for all except emergency benefits?a policy that was greatly in place even before the 1996 reforms.

The second factor is day of entry right into the united States. Special, qualified immigrants who entered after respectable 22, 1996 room barred indigenous SSI and food stamps until they come to be citizens and also from TANF, Medicaid, and also SCHIP for five years after entry. Standard immigrants, that entered prior to August 22, 1996, have more comprehensive eligibility because that these benefits, in component because states have chosen to pay because that the benefits and also in component because federal regulation enacted due to the fact that 1996 restored some benefits for those currently in the unified States. Together a result, many immigrants who entered before 1996 room eligible because that TANF, Medicaid, SCHIP, and also SSI. Eligibility for food stamps is an ext restricted.

See more: How Long Have The Rolling Stones Been Together, The Rolling Stones

In addition to the two wide criteria, over there are numerous other factors that problem non-citizens’ eligibility because that welfare benefits. Kids born to one of two people qualified or not qualified non-citizens after lock have gotten in the United states are citizens and are therefore eligible for benefits on the very same basis as aboriginal citizens. Refugees and also asylees room eligible for all welfare services for the very first seven year they reside in the U.S., after ~ which their eligibility is greatly reduced. Non-citizens who have worked for ten years and armed forces personnel and also their dependents space eligible for all benefits. Finally, some emergency benefits?especially Medicaid?are listed to all non-citizens.