How the Red overcome Raised fifty percent a exchange rate Dollars for Haiti ­and built Six Homes

Even together the group has publicly commemorated its work, insider accounts detail a wire of failures

by Justin Elliott, audioeditorfree.com, and also Laura Sullivan, NPR June 3, 2015

The neighborhood of Campeche sprawls up a steep hillside in Haiti’s resources city, Port-au-Prince. Goats rustle in trash that goes forever uncollected. Children kick a deflated volleyball in a dusty lot listed below a wall surface with a hand-painted logo design of the American Red Cross.

You are watching: How many homes did red cross build in haiti

In late 2011, the Red Cross released a multimillion-dollar job to transform the desperately poor area, which to be hit difficult by the earthquake that struck Haiti the year before. The main emphasis of the task — referred to as LAMIKA, one acronym in creole for “A much better Life in mine Neighborhood” — was building hundreds of permanent homes.

The Latest


Internal Reports: Red Cross might Not Know how Millions Were spent July 21

Red overcome Holds a press Conference In Haiti. The Doesn’t walk Well. June 12

Reddit chat through the reporters June 12


Documents: inside The Red Cross’ Haiti Failures


*

Confidential memo alerts of “failed results”

Report on key project find no “contributions of any type of sort come the well being the households”

Red cross CEO emails around “wonderful helicopter idea” to spend money


Today, not one home has actually been developed in Campeche. Countless residents live in shacks made of rusty paper metal, without accessibility to potable water, electrical energy or an easy sanitation. Once it rains, their houses flood and residents bail the end mud and also water.

The Red Cross received an outpouring that donations after the quake, nearly half a exchange rate dollars.

The team has publicly commemorated its work. However in fact, the Red Cross has repeatedly failed on the floor in Haiti. Confidential memos, emails indigenous worried height officers, and accounts of a dozen frustrated and disappointed insiders display the charity has damaged promises, squandered donations, and also made dubious insurance claims of success.

The Red Cross states it has listed homes to much more than 130,000 people. Yet the actual number of permanent homes the group has constructed in all of Haiti: six.

After the earthquake, Red overcome CEO Gail McGovern unveiled ambitious plans come “develop brand-new communities.” nobody has ever before been built.

Aid establishments from about the people have struggled after the earthquake in Haiti, the western Hemisphere’s poorest country. Yet audioeditorfree.com and NPR’s investigation shows that plenty of of the Red Cross’s failings in Haiti room of its very own making. They room also component of a larger pattern in which the organization has botched shipment of aid after catastrophes such as Superstorm Sandy. Regardless of its difficulties, the Red Cross continues to be the charityof choice for simple Americans and also corporations alike after natural disasters.

One concern that has actually hindered the Red Cross’ work-related in Haiti is one overreliance on foreigners who could not speak French or Creole, current and former employees say.

In a blistering 2011 memo, the then-director the the Haiti program, Judith St. Fort, created that the team was failing in Haiti and also that senior managers had actually made “very disturbing” remarks disparaging Haitian employees. St. Fort, that is Haitian American, composed that the comments included, “he is the only difficult working one among them” and “the ones the we have actually hired are not solid so we probably should not pay close attention to Haitian CVs.”

The Red Cross i will not ~ disclose details of exactly how it has actually spent the numerous millions that dollars donated because that Haiti. But our reporting reflects that less money got to those in need than the Red Cross has said.

Lacking the specialization to mountain its very own projects, the Red Cross finished up offering much of the money come other groups to carry out the work. Those groups took the end a item of every dollar come cover overhead and also management. Even on the jobs done through others, the Red Cross had actually its own far-reaching expenses – in one case, including up come a 3rd of the project’s budget.

Where go the fifty percent billion raised for Haiti go? The Red Cross won’t say.


In statements, the Red Cross cited the challenges all groups have challenged in post-quake Haiti, consisting of the country’s dysfunctional land title system.

“Like plenty of humanitarian organizations responding in Haiti, the American Red cross met complications in relation to government coordination delays, disputes over land ownership, delays at Haitian customs, difficulties finding qualified staff that were in brief supply and high demand, and the cholera outbreak, amongst other challenges,” the charity said.

The group said the responded quickly to interior concerns, consisting of hiring an skilled to train employee on cultural competency after ~ St. Fort’s memo. When the group won’t carry out a malfunction of that is projects, the Red Cross stated it has done more than 100. The projects include repairing 4,000 homes, offering several thousand households temporary shelters, donating $44 million because that food after ~ the earthquake, and helping fund the building and construction of a hospital.

“Millions of Haitians room safer, healthier, much more resilient, and far better prepared for future disasters thanks to generous donations to the American Red Cross,” McGovern created in a recent report marking the 5th anniversary that the earthquake.

In other promotional materials, the Red Cross claimed it has actually helped “more than 4.5 million” individual Haitians “get earlier on your feet.”

It has not listed details to ago up the claim. And Jean-Max Bellerive, Haiti’s prime minister at the time of the earthquake, doubts the figure, mentioning the country’s entire population is only about 10 million.

“No, no,” Bellerive stated of the Red Cross’ claim, “it’s not possible.”

When the earthquake struck Haiti in January 2010, the Red cross was dealing with a crisis of its own. McGovern had become chief executive just 18 month earlier, inheriting a deficit and also an organization that had challenged scandals after 9/11 and also Katrina.

*
Gail McGovern (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Inside the Red Cross, the Haiti disaster was viewed as “a spectacular fundraising opportunity,” recalled one previous official who assisted organize the effort. Michelle Obama, the NFL and also a long list the celebrities appealed because that donations come the group.

The Red Cross maintained soliciting money well after it had sufficient for the emergency relief the is the group’s stock in trade. Physicians Without Borders, in contrast, quit fundraising off the earthquake after ~ it decided it had enough money. The donations come the Red Cross assisted the team erase that is more-than $100 million deficit.

The Red Cross eventually raised far an ext than any kind of other charity.

A year after ~ the quake, McGovern announced the the Red cross would use the donations to make a lasting affect in Haiti.

We inquiry the Red overcome to display us about its projects in Haiti therefore we can see the outcomes of its work. That declined. So earlier this year we went to Campeche to see among the group’s signature tasks for ourselves.

Street merchants in the dusty neighborhood immediately pointed us to Jean Jean Flaubert, the head that a neighborhood group that the Red Cross set up as a regional sounding board.

Sitting through us in their sparse one-room office, Flaubert and also his colleagues flourished angry talking around the Red Cross. They pointed come the lack of progress in the neighborhood and also the healthy salaries paid to expatriate aid workers.

“What the Red overcome told us is that they are coming right here to adjust Campeche. Totally readjust it,” said Flaubert. “Now I execute not know the adjust that they space talking about. Ns think the Red overcome is functioning for themselves.”

The Red Cross’ initial setup said the focus would be structure homes — an interior proposal placed the number at 700. Each would have actually finished floors, toilets, showers, also rainwater collection systems. The homes were claimed to be perfect in January 2013.

*
The Red cross promised to build hundreds of new homes in Campeche however none have been built. Plenty of residents quiet live in crude shacks. (Marie Arago, distinct to audioeditorfree.com)

None of that ever before happened. Carline Noailles, who was the project’s manager in Washington, stated it was endlessly delayed because the Red overcome “didn’t have actually the know-how.”

Another former official who worked on the Campeche job said, “Everything takes 4 times as long since it would be micromanaged indigenous DC, and also they had actually no advance experience.”

Shown an English-language push release native the Red overcome website, Flaubert was stunned to find out of the project’s $24 million spending plan — and that the is due to end next year.

“Not just is not doing it,” Flaubert said, “now I’m discovering that the Red overcome is leaving following year. Ns don’t understand that.” (The Red Cross says it walk tell neighborhood leaders around the end date. It additionally accused united state of “creating ill will certainly in the community which may give rise come a security incident.”)

The project has since been reshaped and also downscaled. A road is gift built. Part existing residences have got earthquake reinforcement and a couple of schools space being repaired. Some solar street lights have actually been installed, though countless broke and residents speak others room unreliable.

The group’s most recent press release ~ above the project cites accomplishments such together training school children in catastrophe response.

See more: How Long Does Navy Boot Camp Last, Surviving Navy Boot Camp

The Red Cross said it has to scale ago its housing plans since it couldn’t gain the legal rights to land. No homes will it is in built.

Other Red Cross infrastructure projects additionally fizzled.

A Red Cross initiative to save Haitians native cholera to be crippled by interior issues. “None of these world had to die,” claimed a Haitian official.