Share every sharing choices for: every 4 living former very first ladies have now condemned family separation

previous living presidents and first ladies pose for a picture at former first lady Barbara Bush’s funeral. Paul Morse/George W. Bush Presidential center via Getty images
All 4 living former an initial ladies have actually now condemned chairman Donald Trump’s “zero tolerance” plan that has separated 2,000 youngsters from their parents in 6 weeks’ time, calling the exercise “horrific” and “traumatizing.”

The statements from Rosalynn Carter, Hillary Clinton, Laura Bush, and also Michelle Obama join a chorus of bipartisan blame of the family members separations ~ above the US-Mexico border — an inexplicable step given that previous presidents and their family members usually don’t criticize the current administration.

You are watching: How many first ladies are still alive

Here’s what they said:

Rosalynn Carter: “Disgraceful and also a dead to ours country”

Rosalynn Carter, the mam of former President Jimmy Carter, referred to as family separation “disgraceful and a shame to our country” in a declare to alphabet News.

“When i was first lady, I worked to speak to attention to the plight of refugees fleeing Cambodia for Thailand, I checked out Thailand and also witnessed firsthand the trauma the parents and children be separated by circumstance beyond their control,” Carter said.

Hillary Clinton: “A moral and also humanitarian crisis”

Former very first lady and also Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton used her time top top the phase at the Women’s Forum of brand-new York luncheon to denounce Trump’s “horrific” policy. She cited the photos of youngsters in cages and also the Honduran woman who insurance claims her son was taken from her while she to be breastfeeding:

This is a moral and also humanitarian crisis. Every one of us who’s ever before been a parental or a grandparent, one aunt, a large sister, any one of us who’s ever held a kid in ours arms, every human being being with a sense of compassion and also decency, must be outraged.

Clinton rebutted Trump’s cases that separating households was legit required:

Separating families is no mandated by legislation at all. That is an bald lie. And also it’s incumbent on all of us — journalists and also citizens alike — to call it simply that.

Clinton finished her impassioned speech v a jab at Attorney basic Jeff Sessions and also press secretary sarah Sanders, who have called the matter of separating family members a “biblical” duty:

Those who selectively use the holy bible to justify this cruelty space ignoring a central tenet the Christianity. ... Jesus said, “Suffer the little children depend me”; he did no say, “Let the youngsters suffer.”

Laura Bush: “It division my heart”

Former first lady Laura Bush, the mam of former President George W. Bush, addressed her concerns in a letter to the Washington short article published June 17. Bush made clear that she felt Trump’s “zero tolerance” immigrant policy, imposed by Sessions, to be wrong:

“I live in a border state. I appreciate the need to enforce and also protect our international boundaries, but this zero-tolerance plan is cruel,” bush explained. “It is immoral. And also it division my heart.”

She continued:

Our federal government should no be in the business of warehousing children in converted crate stores or making plans to ar them in tent urban in the desert exterior of El Paso. These photos are eerily reminiscent of the internment camps because that U.S. Citizens and noncitizens of Japanese descent during civilization War II, now considered to have been one of the most shameful episodes in U.S. History. We likewise know that this therapy inflicts trauma; those who have actually been interned have been twice as likely to experience cardiovascular an illness or dice prematurely than those that were not interned.

See more: How Many Guns Did Stephen Paddock Have, 2017 Las Vegas Shooting

Michelle Obama: “Truth transcends party”

Former very first lady Michelle Obama tweeted an proof of Bush’s op-ed, speak “sometimes fact transcends party.”

Sometimes reality transcends party. Https://

— Michelle Obama (
MichelleObama) June 18, 2018

What about Melania Trump?

First lady Melania trump — who hardly ever speaks out on policy issues — made a pass out statement on family members separations, placing the onus ~ above both Republicans and also Democrats come eradicate the practice in a statement from she spokesperson, Stephanie Grisham:

Mrs. Trump hates to see kids separated from your families and hopes both political parties of the aisle can lastly come together to accomplish successful immigration reform. She to trust we must be a country that complies with all laws, but likewise a nation that governs v heart.

Meanwhile, Ivanka Trump, who has actually positioned herself together the voice of the administration on children and family issues, has actually been silent.

Will you assistance’s explanatory journalism?

Millions turn to to understand what’s happening in the news. Our mission has never been more an important than the is in this moment: to empower with understanding. Financial contributions from our readers space a an essential part of sustaining our resource-intensive occupational and assist us keep our journalism free for all. Please take into consideration making a contribution to now to assist us save our work totally free for all.