‘Do We have the right to Kill?’: California Suspends fatality Penalty

Gov. Gavin Newsom of California announced a moratorium on resources punishment on Wednesday, giving a momentary reprieve because that 737 inmates on death row.

You are watching: How many death row inmates in california


Do we deserve to kill? that’s a deep — an gift question. I don’t think we do. Girlfriend know, I know those things people think eye for eye, however if friend rape, us don’t rape. And also I think if someone kills, us don’t kill. We’re much better than that. For this reason this moratorium developments that principle. And we space as i speak, as I speak, shutting down, removing the equipment in the death chamber at san Quentin, symbolically and also substantively, come send a post that we’re much better than this.



Gov. Gavin Newsom that California announced a moratorium on capital punishment top top Wednesday, offering a momentary reprieve because that 737 inmates on death row.CreditCredit...Eric Risberg/Associated Press

LOS ANGELES — Gov. Gavin Newsom announced a moratorium on funding punishment top top Wednesday, providing a short-lived reprieve because that the 737 inmates top top the state’s death row, the biggest in the west Hemisphere.

The move is highly symbolic due to the fact that legal difficulties have currently stalled executions in California; the last one was in 2006. However death penalty opponents hope that since of California’s size and political importance, the governor’s action will give new urgency to initiatives to end executions in various other states as famous support for the fatality penalty wanes.

Mr. Newsom, a longtime opponent of funding punishment, quote its high cost, gyeongju disparities in its application and wrongful convictions, and questioned whether society has the appropriate to take a life.

“I know civilization think eye for eye, but if girlfriend rape, we don’t rape,” the said. “And i think if someone kills, us don’t kill. We’re better than that.”


He continued, “I cannot sign off on executing hundreds and also hundreds of human beings, knowing — understanding — that among them will certainly be innocent human being beings.”

Supporters of capital punishment stated the relocate went versus the will of the state’s residents. California voters have actually rejected one initiative come abolish the death penalty and in 2016, they directly approved Proposition 66 to help speed the up.

“I think this would certainly be a bolder step and also I think he’s gained to be aware of the politics downside,” said Michael D. Rushford, chairman of the Criminal Justice legit Foundation, an organization in Sacramento that favors the fatality penalty and also helped breeze the ballot proposition, speaking prior to the governor’s announcement. “Voters have had multiple avenues in California over three decades to give up the death penalty and also they’ve closeup of the door them under at every chance.”

Former Gov. Jerry Brown, a liberal who made criminal justice revolutionary in California a hallmark the his legacy, withstood calls to commute California’s death sentences prior to he left office in January.

His refusal remained in some methods a politics gift to Mr. Newsom, giving him the chance to take a high-profile position with nationwide significance beforehand in his administration. In 2004, Mr. Newsom take it a similar tack as market of mountain Francisco, as soon as he legalized gay marital relationship in the city in ~ a time when also the democratic Party opposed it.


With funding punishment, Mr. Newsom is no at the vanguard of the the opposite movement. The fatality penalty has been top top the decrease in America for 2 decades. Yet it has come to be a defining issue for him, widening the splitting line in between California and also the policies of chairman Trump, who has talked out in favor of the fatality penalty, also for drug dealers.

After the news of Mr. Newsom’s decision broke, Mr. Trump said on Twitter: “Defying voters, the governor of California will certainly halt all death penalty executions that 737 rock cold killers. Friends and also families the the constantly forgotten VICTIMS are not thrilled, and neither to be I!”

Speaking several hrs later, Mr. Newsom claimed he had actually met with families of victims and also they had expressed passionate however conflicting see on funding punishment. But the branch made it clear that his decision came under to his own conscience, prodded by imminent decisions such as whether to assistance the state’s lethal injection protocol.

An executive, management order Mr. Newsom signed ~ above Wednesday does 3 things: grants reprieves come the inmates at this time on death row — they will still it is in under a death sentence, yet not at danger of execution; close the door the execution chamber at san Quentin prison; and also withdraws the state’s lethal injection protocol, the formally approved procedure for transferring out executions.

“Three out of four nations in the people know far better and space doing better,” Mr. Newsom said. “They’ve denomination the fatality penalty. That time California join those ranks.”

Supporters of the fatality penalty guess legal difficulties to any moratorium. Michele Hanisee, the president of the association of Deputy district Attorneys in Los Angeles stated that reprieves because that condemned inmates would certainly be, “in effect, invalidating the law” the California voters have actually repeatedly affirmed, regardless of the liberal values that overcome the state.

“I think the surprises me too, sometimes,” she said. “California is liberal, ns think us all know that. We have Hollywood, and the music industry, which i think affects people’s thinking. I think through the fatality penalty it comes down to specifically, of cases. We have actually serial killers and also lots of bad people in California.”


Mr. Newsom claimed voters were well conscious that he opposed funding punishment when they elected him. In 2012, he was the only statewide main to publicly support a ballot initiative come repeal it, and also he has said in interviews that the inquiry of what the would execute if confronted with the possibility of one execution top top his watch weighed heavily on him.

Mr. Newsom’s relocate will surely it is in applauded by liberal activists, members of his very own party and also many conservatives, some of whom have involved see the death penalty together exorbitantly costly and have argued against it on economic grounds.

Three various other governors — in Oregon, Colorado and also Pennsylvania — have issued moratoriums ~ above the fatality penalty. In various other states, the practice has been denomination by either legislatures or courts. The latest was Washington, which critical year came to be the 20th state come end capital punishment when the State supreme Court ruled it unconstitutional, after ~ a moratorium approve by the governor.

“A moratorium in California has huge symbolic value,” said Robert Dunham, the executive, management director of the fatality Penalty information Center. “It’s part of the momentum we room seeing.”

But in 2016, Californians doubled under on the death penalty, granting a measure that centralized the appeals process, which has generally taken about 25 years in California because that condemned prisoners. The initiative, which was backed by countless law enforcement officials and prosecutors, passed with 51 percent of the vote, belying California’s national photo as place where national politics was steadily moving to the left. The was authorized at the same time that voters legalized marijuana.

Even without a moratorium, funding punishment in California has stalled in the courts because of difficulties to the state’s use of a three-drug protocol, which can reason painful deaths. Brand-new death sentences have actually been top top the wane.

But the endurance of the fatality penalty in California has actually acted as a inspect on the nationwide movement versus capital punishment, said Shilpi Agarwal, a employee attorney in ~ the American civil Liberties Union in mountain Francisco who is involved in the lethal injection litigation.


“It is a state people look come to collection the tone for nationwide policy,” she said. “The truth that so plenty of states have abolished the fatality penalty — but California there is no — has given civilization cover for this rigid that human being are still donate the death penalty.”

In an interview critical fall throughout his campaign for governor, Mr. Newsom quote his irish Catholic, Jesuit background, saying he opposed resources punishment for “moral, ethical and also economic reasons.”

He said he had actually been reading former President bill Clinton’s memoir, highlighting passages about how he confronted the death penalty as governor of Arkansas. Inquiry if the would sign a death warrant if a plan execution got to his office, he said then, “I’m not all set to answer the question, due to the fact that I’m not prepared to price the question. And also in that preparation comes a many soul searching.”

California governors are minimal in their power to commute sentences, however they do have actually the power to issue temporary reprieves. A moratorium, claimed Stefanie Faucher the the 8th Amendment Project, an organization that opposes capital punishment, is “functionally a series of reprieves.”

In order to commute death sentences come life in jail for death row inmates that have a former felony, which numerous do, Mr. Newsom would need approval native the California can be fried Court.

California, i beg your pardon reinstated the death penalty in 1978, has 737 inmates on fatality row in mountain Quentin prison, about a 4 minutes 1 of the total number of death row inmates in the joined States. However only 13 executions have actually been carried out because 1978. The critical one, in 2006, to be of Clarence beam Allen, who was executed 23 years after his conviction because that hiring who to carry out three murders.

Opponents that the fatality penalty, including Mr. Newsom, have long argued that the practice is rife with racial disparities and also is no justified through the high cost to state taxpayers. One study, in 2011, discovered that California pays $184 million a year to sustain capital punishment — or close to an accumulated $5 billion since the exercise was reinstituted in 1978.


In February, Mr. Newsom intervened in a high-profile fatality row case that for years activists have claimed was a prime instance of gyeongju injustice.

Kevin Cooper, a black male who to be convicted of four brutal killing by stabbing in 1983, has long kept his innocence. His supporters have actually put forward proof that he to be framed by san Bernardino officers. Mr. Newsom ordered DNA experimentation in the case, something the state officials had refused to execute in the past.

The possibility of wrongful convictions — nationally, more than 150 world on death row have actually been exonerated because the mid-1970s, according to the nationwide Coalition to Abolish the death Penalty — has likewise energized the the contrary movement, roughly the country and also in California.

See more: How Many Serial Killers Are From Washington State, Which State Has Produced The Most Serial Killers

Last April in California, a male who had been on fatality row because that 25 years because that murdering a young girl, a former farmworker called Vicente Figueroa Benavides, was freed after a court established that testimony provided at his trial to be false.