The president has actually made this case for over 2 years — however there is still no evidence. (Meg Kelly/The Washington Post)
“This is a deep intellectual trouble that is plaguing this city, i m sorry is the we’ve had thousands of Americans die year after ~ year ~ year since of threats crossing our southern border.”


— Stephen Miller, an elderly adviser to president Trump, in one interview v “Fox News Sunday,” Feb. 17, 2019


*
2021 Election: finish coverage and analysisArrowRight


Miller slipped this heat in the final seconds that his controversial interview with hold Chris Wallace over President Trump’s emergency declaration to fund a wall along the southern border, so part viewers could have let go it. Yet it’s one astonishing statement, arguing that undocumented immigrant kill countless Americans every year.

You are watching: How many americans killed by illegal immigrants


The White house did no respond to a query concerning Miller’s math, yet other anti-immigration advocates have made similar claims. Rep. Mo Brooks (R-Ala.) asserted in December the there are “thousands of americans who space dead each year due to the fact that the Democrats’ refuse to secure ours borders.” president Trump declared in 2018 that 63,000 Americans have actually been killed by illegal immigrants due to the fact that the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, which works out to about 3,700 a year.


But there is no evidence these cases are true. In fact, the accessible evidence says these cases are false. This is a good example about how a paucity of data enables political proponents to jump to conclusions.


First, part context: there is no nationwide data set on crime committed by undocumented immigrants, so researchers have actually tried come tease the answer native less-than-complete data. Yet research after study mirrors that illegal immigration does no lead to increased crime, violence or medicine problems. In fact, the studies suggest that undocumented immigrants commit crime at lower rates 보다 native-born Americans.


A 2018 study published in the peer-reviewed journal Criminology, led through Michael Light, a criminologist at the college of Wisconsin in ~ Madison, examined whether areas with higher percentages the undocumented immigrants have higher rates the violent crime such together murder or rape. The answer: says with larger shares the undocumented immigrants often tended to have lower crime rates than states with smaller shares in the years 1990 through 2014. Comparable results were uncovered in an additional peer-reviewed research by the same researchers the looked at nonviolent crime, such as medicine arrests and driving under the affect (DUI) arrests.


Similarly, the libertarian Cato academy in 2018 looked at 2015 criminal conviction data among undocumented immigrant in Texas — among the couple of states to document whether a person who has actually been arrested is in the country illegally or not. Researcher Alex Nowrasteh discovered that criminal conviction and also arrest rates in Texas for undocumented immigrant were reduced than those that native-born Americans because that homicide, sex-related assault and larceny.


“As a percent of their respective populations, there were 50 percent under criminal convictions that illegal immigrants than of native-born americans in Texas in 2015,” Nowrasteh wrote. “The criminal conviction price for legal immigrants was about 66 percent listed below the native-born rate.”


In 2015, there to be 785 complete homicide convictions in Texas. The those, native-born Americans were convicted the 709 homicides (a conviction rate of 3.1 per 100,000), illegal immigrants were judge of 46 homicides (2.6 every 100,000), and legal immigrants were convicted of 30 homicides (1 every 100,000). In other words, homicide conviction rates for illegal and legal immigrants were 16 percent and also 67 percent below those the native-born Americans, respectively.


Some advocates of restraining immigration have sought to make the situation that undocumented immigrants commit much more crimes by relying ~ above data indigenous the State Criminal Alien help Program (SCAAP), a federal regime that offers states and also localities some reimbursement because that the cost of incarcerating certain criminal non-U. S. Citizens. The federal government Accountability Office (GAO) in July authorize an updated report on SCAAP data, however GAO (and SCAAP) just counts total incarcerations, no individuals. Therefore the numbers are not useful for illustration conclusions about the criminality the undocumented immigrants.

See more: How Many Calories In A Cosmopolitan, The Best Drinks For Dieters


In various other words, the available research shows that, when contrasted with U.S. Citizens, illegal immigrant commit fewer crimes. However we understand that some civilization might controversy that any kind of crime cursed by an illegal extraterrestrial is one also many. Müller is connected in a counting exercise — hundreds of deaths that in concept would not otherwise have happened if the undocumented immigrant had actually not set foot ~ above U.S. Soil.