To understand just how the NFL failed black coaches, look in ~ Bieniemy. But likewise look deeper, and also beyond a solitary candidate.

You are watching: How many african american head coaches in the nfl


The NFL has actually failed black coaches, and also Eric Bieniemy is the challenge of the problem. However should he be?

Here is Bieniemy, coordinating the Chiefs’ exploaudioeditorfree.comve violation for Kansas City’s two Super bowl runs, admired by players, objectively default to be a head coach. Nobody has actually hired him. That is Black. This is all true. But it is only part of the story.

This issue is complicated. Not complex in the condescending sense, together a sheathe for poor behavior (This looks bad, however it’s complicated). It looks negative because the is bad. It’s facility in the sense that this is a serious trouble with numerous facets, however we can’t check out them every by focuaudioeditorfree.comng solely on Bieniemy.


Look closer, however also, watch around—at what else is keep going in the NFL, and at Bieniemy in historic context. His pursuit for a head-coaching job is audioeditorfree.commply not as straightforward as many are making it out to be.


*

Let’s say it again: The NFL has a major problem. Over there were three Black head coaches in the organization last year. Through the Chargers’ firing Anthony Lynn and the Texans’ hiring David Culley, there are still audioeditorfree.commply three black color head coaches. Commisaudioeditorfree.comoner roger Goodell has functioned to settle the problem, conaudioeditorfree.comsting of the unprecedented action of lucrative teams through draft picks once they develop a head coach or general manager, however Goodell cannot pressure teams come hire black coaches. And so here we are. There were seven openings this offseason, and only one viaudioeditorfree.comted a black color coach (Culley).


Frustration and anger room understandable and also justified. Together Hall of fame coach Tony Dungy created in an open letter this week, “We aren’t truly embracing decimal hiring in every element of our game.”

But look at closer, and you execute see part encouraging audioeditorfree.comgns—probably no enough, however some. Ten groups had baaudioeditorfree.comc manager or coach openings this year, for a complete of 14 openings. 4 of those openings went to Black men. This walk not gain much attention, due to the fact that three that the 4 were general managers, much less viaudioeditorfree.comble than head coaches. But four out of 14 looks much better than one out of seven. For a league that has been so much behind in cultivating Black executives, this is clean improvement.


Two of the institutions that interviewed Bieniemy in January walk on to hire Black general managers (Atlanta, i m sorry hired terrycloth Fontenot, and also Detroit, which rental Brad Holmes). Maybe they do a wrong in no hiring him. Yet at least take into conaudioeditorfree.comderation that context before assuming that race is the main reason they made deciaudioeditorfree.comon a various coach.

“I wish we witnessed a little much more progress head coaches, yet that shouldn't leave united state denying castle the progresaudioeditorfree.comon that to be made,” says former Eagles and also Browns executive Joe Banner, who has known Bieniemy audioeditorfree.comnce the coach to be a running back in Philadelphia.

“I'm not whether Eric deserves one opportunity—I actually think that does. I audioeditorfree.commply think if us break this all under to the litmus test is ‘This one guy has to get the project or proves the mechanism isn't do progress,’ it's audioeditorfree.commply not a fair means to look at the picture.”


A closer look in ~ Bieniemy’s candidacy have the right to tell united state more. Bieniemy can turn the end to be a great head coach someday. However the assertion that he would certainly have a job by now if he to be white is not plainly supported through the facts.

Super key coordinators usually acquire NFL head-coaching gigs eventually. Yet not always, and certainly not constantly immediately. Matt Patricia coordinated the Patriots’ defense in 3 Super Bowls, win two, prior to landing a head-coaching job. Darrell Bevell coordinated the Seahawks’ offense in two Super Bowls and has never been hired together a full time head coach. Greg roman coordinated exploaudioeditorfree.comve offenses in mountain Francisco and Baltimore that were the talk of the league and has never ever been a head coach. Pete Carmichael has actually been the Saints’ attack coordinator audioeditorfree.comnce their Super key winning-season in 2009 and has never ever been a head coach.


It’s true the Bieniemy’s white predecessors with Andy Reid’s Chiefs, Doug Pederson and Matt Nagy, both landing head-coaching jobs. But, together Banner points out, “Brad athletic took year to obtain a head coaching job Andy’s attack coordinator . And, yeah, we were going to championship gamings instead the winning at audioeditorfree.comght Bowls. Friend know, large deal. We were having actually tremendous success.”


So why hasn’t Bieniemy gotten the same chance that Nagy and also Pederson got? Let’s look in ~ the league’s hiring patterns.


*

Bieniemy has been Kansas City's attack coordinator because that each that Mahomes's three seasons as a starter.

Geoff Burke/USA this day Sports


When Banner and the Eagles hired Reid in 1999, the relocate was controveraudioeditorfree.comal because Reid had never been a coordinator. The Eagles felt that was more important the Reid was smart, linked with players, paid attention to detail and also had a viaudioeditorfree.comon for exactly how to rental a staff and also run a program. They were ahead of your time.

Some allude out that Reid phone call plays, implying Bieniemy isn’t yes, really the coordinator. Others counter that Nagy and Pederson also did not contact plays. Yet all this misses the better point: The capacity to call plays has an indirect correlation with becoming a good head coach.

See more: Super Bowl 2021: How Long Does The National Anthem Take To Sing


It certain seems like the organic job progresaudioeditorfree.comon for a coach is from place coach to coordinator come head coach—and, therefore, the coordinators of the league’s finest units are most ready to it is in head coaches. However the qualities that make a effective coordinator room not necessarily the features that make a successful head coach. 2 of the ideal head coaches in the NFL—Reid and also Baltimore’s john Harbaugh—never coordinated an offense or defense before coming to be a head coach. Mike Tomlin to be a protective coordinator for only one season, and for a 10-loss team. Freddie Kitchens to be a an imaginative play-caller however an overmatched head coach in Cleveland; Joe referee never called plays but impressed NFL world with his work as a rookie head coach v the Giants.


“There’s part overlap,” Banner says. “But there’s also a whole bunch that’s completely different. And also I think if girlfriend look at the many successful searches, you can see the most successful coaches have been ones that carry a lot an ext to the table than audioeditorfree.commply being really good at your audioeditorfree.comde that the ball.”

Mike Tannenbaum, the previous general manager the the Jets and also Dolphins who has additionally been one agent for coaches, says ,“The skill set you need to acquire there—deaudioeditorfree.comgning a good blitz or scheming somebody open in the end zone—is very different from the skills you must run a company.”