Three percent or 94 percent? are abortions just a small part of the array of planned Parenthood’s services, as supporters of abortion legal rights say? Or is to plan Parenthood mostly an abortion provider the masquerades as a reproductive health and wellness organization, as enemies of abortion legal rights say?
It depends on the measure up you usage to make her case. Both numbers are gift paraded roughly as dispute over plan Parenthood’s fetal organization donations continues. The reality Checker obviously bring away no view on abortion rights, fetal organization donations or defunding to plan Parenthood.
You are watching: How many abortions does planned parenthood do
First, right here is a malfunction of plan Parenthood’s “services,” defined as a “discrete clinical interaction.”
According to the 2013-14 annual report, plan Parenthood’s affiliated clinics provided 10.6 million services for 2.7 million clients in 2013. “Other women’s health services” space pregnancy tests and also “prenatal services,” which are described as “care you get from a health treatment provider, such together a doctor or midwife, during pregnancy.” this services may take ar at a planned Parenthood clinic, or may be referred the end to another provider. “Contraception” consists of emergency contraception kits, vasectomies and also female sterilization procedures. “Other services” includes fostering referrals and family exercise services for men and women.
Out the the 10.6 million services, 327,653 the them to be abortion actions — i beg your pardon leads united state to the plan Parenthood figure.
When all services are counting equally, abortion measures do account because that 3 percent of plan Parenthood’s full services.
But there are noticeable differences in between these services. For example, a very first trimester abortion can cost up come $1,500, according to the plan Parenthood web site. Yet an emergency contraceptive pill costs roughly $45 and also a urine pregnancy test costs roughly $10 at a pharmacy. An abortion is a different type of procedure 보다 a vasectomy, or testing for sexually sent epidemic or diseases, or a vaccine for person papilloma virus (HPV), and so forth.
While each company is provided separately, plenty of clients received multiple services. A woman may gain a pregnant test, birth control and also a pap smear, yet she would certainly be counted three times, when for every service, in the annual report.
Those that oppose abortion rights have actually criticized this definition, saying the 3 percent figure misleads the public. In a recent New York Post op-ed, National testimonial editor Rich Lowry wrote a series of analogies to argue the the 3 percent figure “is crafted to obscure the truth of to plan Parenthood’s business:”
The sponsors the the new York City Marathon might count each tiny cup that water castle hand out (some 2 million cups, contrasted with 45,000 runners) and also say they are mostly in the hydration business.
Or significant League Baseball teams can say the they sell about 20 million warm dogs and play 2,430 gamings in a season, so baseball is just .012 percent the what castle do.
Supporters of to plan Parenthood desire to usage its wellness services together leverage to maintain its abortions, together if girlfriend can’t get one there is no the other.
Slate’s Rachael Larimore, the left-leaning digital magazine’s conservative an elderly editor, called this the “most meaningless abortion statistic ever.”
SBA List, which opposes abortion rights, arrives at its 94 percent number by comparing abortions to two various other categories of services that are provided to pregnant patient — or “pregnancy services.”
Recall the earlier breakdown of to plan Parenthood’s services. SBA list compares abortions come the variety of prenatal services (18,684) and adoption referrals to various other agencies (1,880). Using this measure, abortions carry out account for 94 percent that the combined three categories.
But plan Parenthood does not administer the variety of pregnant clients it has in a year, or what solutions they received. So pregnant women might have pertained to the clinic to get a business other 보다 (or in enhancement to) one abortion, prenatal care or adoption referral — the just three solutions counted in SBA List’s criteria. SBA List also does not include 1.13 million pregnant tests, a part of which might be offered to a pregnant woman.
Multiple prenatal services might be readily available to one woman, therefore the prenatal solutions number may not compare directly to the number of adoption measures (assuming one abortion every woman). The 2013 report go not determine the number of prenatal clients, yet Planned Parenthood number from 2009 give us an idea of how these numbers deserve to differ. Planned Parenthood reported 7,021 prenatal client in 2009, but additionally reported in that is 2010 yearly report that it provided 40,489 prenatal services in 2009.
Planned Parenthood clinics likewise refer pregnant patient to outside providers because that prenatal services. A spokeswoman freshly told PolitiFact that the organization does not document the variety of such referrals. (However, to plan Parenthood made this info public lengthy ago. Annual report numbers from 1996 and also 1997 show the number and type of steps that to be referred out in those years.)
Knowing the full number of referrals for miscellaneous pregnancy-related services would offer a fuller picture. Because that example, to plan Parenthood the the Rocky mountains partners with a midwifery exercise for its Prenatal to add Program, assigning case managers to assist pregnant women with parenting classes, counselors and also a registered dietician. Planned Parenthood Mid and also South Michigan associate pregnant ladies with neighborhood resources because that a range of pregnancy-related services.
Advocates ~ above both sides have actually used other steps in an initiative to portray a more representative number of fostering services together a re-publishing of complete services. Yet all face limitations, together Planned Parenthood — a non-profit — does not have to release financial information past its legitimate requirements.
Some, including SBA List, have actually attempted come quantify just how much of to plan Parenthood’s clinic revenues make up revenues native abortions. Typically, this calculate is do by taking the variety of abortions, multiply them through the average expense of abortions advertised by planned Parenthood clinics, and also dividing the number by the organization’s full non-government health services revenue.
The main Planned Parenthood internet site says first-trimester abortions can price up come $1,500. Part affiliate clinic net sites administer a variety of costs: a west Pennsylvania clinic lists $390 to $1,090 because that abortions, and first trimester abortion is priced at $515 in Arizona.
Non-government health services profits refer come money gathered for health treatment services, such as abortions, that are not spanned by federal government programs. (The largest resource of revenue for Planned Parenthood is federal government funding, however federal funds can’t be supplied for abortions. Planned Parenthood does not separate its federal and state funds in its annual report.)
Using this calculation, advocates and also opponents the abortion rights have calculated somewhere between 15 percent and 37 percent the the organization’s yearly non-government health services revenue comes from abortion services. Depending on which price girlfriend use, girlfriend can even get as much as 55 percent. But this form of math is speculative and has limitations. Because that one, the does no take into account slide payment scales because that patients or reflect costs absorbed by insurance.
Another means to calculation is through the number of total patients. Recall Planned Parenthood wellness centers witnessed 2.7 million patient (men and women) in 2013. If the 327,653 abortion measures were provided to separation, personal, instance patients, patient who received abortions would certainly account because that 12 percent of total patients.
There were 4.6 million clinical visits in 2013. If each mrs who received an abortion visited the clinic only as soon as for the procedure, abortions comprised 7 percent of visits the year. If each woman went to twice (a Q&A top top the net site says women have to schedule a follow-up appointment after an abortion), abortions comprised 14 percent that visits. Yet there is no way of knowing an accurate figure past the 7 percent.
Neither organization listed an on-the-record statement around their methodology come The reality Checker.
The 3 percent number that plan Parenthood offers is misleading, comparing abortion solutions to every other business that it provides. The organization treats each business — pregnant test, STD test, abortion, birth control — equally. Yet there are noticeable difference in between a surgical (or also medical) abortion, and also offering a to pee (or also blood) pregnant test. These solutions are no all comparable in exactly how much they cost or how substantial the service or procedure is.
The 94 percent figure that Susan B. Anthony perform uses also is misleading, comparing abortion solutions to two other varieties of solutions that pregnant women obtain through to plan Parenthood. Yet we don’t understand how many pregnant women Planned Parenthood serves annually or how plenty of they refer to personal providers for prenatal care, since the organization does not report that information.
With minimal data, there is no accurate way to measure how much of planned Parenthood’s activities comprise abortions. Both sides space using meaningless and also incomplete to compare to do their argument, and the public need to be wary of both figures. Thus, both obtain Three Pinocchios.
While plan Parenthood has no legal duty to do its data more public, it is unfortunately that the general public has restricted access to data around the organization. Plan Parenthood could end the speculation–and Pinocchios–by providing a more transparent breakdown of that clients, referrals and also sources that revenues.
See more: How Many Terms Did George Bush Sr Serve, George Bush
Today’s HeadlinesThe most vital news stories of the day, curated by article editors and also delivered every morning.