Jim Watson/AFP/Getty photos

This story is component of a team of stories referred to as
A view of the U.S.-Mexico border line in Nogales, northwestern Mexico. Billy Arias/AFP/Getty images If vault wall-building adventures are any kind of guide, Trump might want to stick come skyscrapers. The existing build-the-wall crusade is neither novel nor specifically well informed by the history of vault border containment efforts. Leaving next the numerous moral inquiries the wall surface raises, specialists say that a 2,000-mile framework project presents substantial challenges in terms of labor, cost, geography, and also effectiveness.

Efforts come block our southerly neighbors have been component of American political discourse for more than a century, since the specter the Pancho Villa and also his revolutionaries loomed end border towns in the beforehand 20th century. These initiatives have met with combined success.

San Diego, i beg your pardon has constantly been among the U.S.-Mexico border’s busiest cross points, placed up at an early stage fencing in 1910. In 1924, the Treasury room floated a proposal come erect one 8-foot-high fence along 160 miles of the California-Mexico boundary line, yet the fence was never ever constructed. In 1925, El Paso suggest a "hog tight, horse high, and bootlegger-proof barbed-wire fence, perhaps electrically charged” to stop the flow of cheap booze during Prohibition.

Border towns and also localities have strung increase their own walls and also barriers, and numerous managements have constructed watchtowers, gates, and also secure ports of entry. In the so late 1970s, the Immigration and also Naturalization organization proposed a collection of barbed wire-topped 12-foot structures close to urban crossings that were insensitively labeling the “Tortilla Curtain” by the press (the plan was scaled ago after news reports zeroed in on building contractors describing how the spicy razor cable would reduced off the fingers and also toes of climbers).

The U.S.-Mexico border fence separating the beaches is seen at Border ar State Park in san Diego, California. Jim Watson/AFP/Getty images In a post-9/11 era of financial anxiety and Minutemen patrolling the borders, scattered fencing no longer sufficed. Consider the border blockades said by Republican presidential candidates in 2012: Minnesota Rep. Michele Bachmann pledged to construct a double-fenced border wall surface from the Pacific to the Gulf that Mexico. Herman Cain walk further, saying that a 20-foot-tall, electrified barrier topped in barbed wire was what us needed.

Texas branch Rick Perry, the incoming energy secretary for the trump card administration, was probably the only candidate in the 2012 race with considerable knowledge of the sprawling southerly border, and also he take it a various approach. He suggested a an ext complex combination of fencing, surveillance technology, and also “boots ~ above the ground.” A border-length fence, the said, would require up come 15 years and also $30 billion, and wouldn’t be “cost-effective.”

While past attempts to secure the border with modern technology have proven to be mirages and money pits (a notable instance being the Boeing-led effort to build a cutting-edge border security mechanism in 2005, i m sorry flamed the end after the company spent much more than $1 billion to construct simply 53 mile of fencing, sensors, and radar), a technological solution would likely cost a fraction of what a solid barrier would.



Aerial check out of the land break-up by the U.S.-Mexico border.
Courtesy of Google photos
And together Perry’s rejection of a full-length physical barrier demonstrates, the closer politicians gain to the border, the an ext they think the idea that a solid wall surface is foolish. Texas politicians familiar with the day-to-day workings of the border—and who have countless constituents that would be required to sell portions of your land to make means for the wall—don’t mince words.

Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-TX 28th District) referred to as the wall “a 14th-century equipment to a 21st-century problem,” and Rep. Will certainly Hurd (R-TX 23rd District), whose ar runs follow me 800 mile of border, claims a wall surface would be “the many expensive and also least effective method to for sure the border.”

Rep. Filemon Vela (D-TX 34th District) claimed in an open letter around the wall idea the Trump might “shove it up his ass.” “He’s not going to develop a wall. The civilization in my district will line increase on the border. He’ll watch a human chain the likes of i m sorry he’s never ever seen.” (In Arizona, leader of the Tohono O’odham Nation, i beg your pardon controls substantial swaths of border territory, have dubbed for was standing Rock-like protests if the wall surface comes come pass.)

Even retired naval Corps Gen. Man Kelly, the brand-new secretary the the department of countryside Security, that will be in charge of creating Trump’s wall, has actually said “a physical obstacle in and also of itself will not do the job.”

Trump has actually repeatedly stated he’s committed to a physical wall that will defend the entire border, but it’s unlikely he’ll produce a new barrier along the full 2,000 miles, because hundreds of miles of fencing already exist.

Thanks to the 2006 for sure Fences Act, a Bush-era initiative, roughly 653 mile have already been spanned in different sections, with a hodgepodge of fencing and barriers, consisting of chain link, post-and-rail fences, and concrete vehicle barriers conveniently sidestepped by anyone on foot. This rather porous potpourri of structures was at first envisioned as 700 miles of strategically put sections that double-fencing; the ways it fell short offer plenty of lessons around the dangers of together projects.

You are watching: How long would it take to build a wall

Like Trump’s present plan, Bush’s wall was pushed forward in 2006 as a defense imperative, billed together an overdue correction to our dangerous, exposed border. Politicians and also advocates whipped constituents and also Congress right into a frenzy: phone lines were jammed in the House and Senate, and also some citizens even mailed bricks to their representatives, symbolizing assistance for the barrier.

Then-Senator Jeff Sessions the Alabama stated the fence to be a height priority, saying in a dispute that “we carry out not have actually operational control of the border.” (He would later argue that structure a wall has “biblical backing.”)

Congress authorized the measure to develop a tactical defense fence v comfortable margins, and a $1.2 billion Homeland Security funding bill come cover costs. (Then-Senators Barack Obama and also Hillary Clinton both vote yes.) however the fencing project quickly became a source of controversy, expense overruns, and embarrassing mistakes.

After receiving conference authorization, Homeland defense Secretary Michael Chertoff realized he would have actually to obtain numerous ecological waivers to develop such a massive project and negotiate with local property owners, consisting of tribal landowners.

Dismissing protocol together a matter of national security, Chertoff offered his strength to waive 36 separate regulations to build the fence, including the Endangered types Act, the safe Drinking Water Act, and also the native American graves Protection and Repatriation Act. (In 2008, a defect leader testified that as soon as he checked out observe fence building on his tribe’s land, pieces of human being remains indigenous grave web page were discovered in the machinery.)

“Criminal activity at the border go not stop for endless conflict or protracted litigation,” Chertoff later on said in a statement. Landowners and localities, consisting of the Texas Border Coalition, an company of mayors, county commissioners, and economists that filed a federal lawsuit versus the construction, would proceed to hit him end land seizure and also eminent domain issues.


Even more damaging to the mission that erecting a safe and secure mexico border wall surface were a collection of mistakes during construction. The HBO documentary La Barda (The Fence) highlights a few, consisting of a stretch constructed six feet into Mexican territory that required to be torn down and also rebuilt for millions of dollars.

Another portion, developed near the financial institutions of the Rio Grande, needed to be put up away native the curving natural border, creating a no man’s land between the two countries. Improper drainage near Nogales, Mexico, developed a 20-foot pool of water the flooded many border-adjacent homes and businesses. The DHS would end up safety $44 million ~ above extra steel it didn’t need.

All of these delays and mistakes added up. According to a reality sheet native the lobbying team Taxpayers for usual Sense, expenses ballooned from initial estimates of $431,000 per mile to $4.5 million a mile for primary fencing and $1.6 million for vehicle barriers. In some unstable terrain, the price per mile topped $12 million.

By 2011, the department of Homeland security cancelled the plan, citing expense overruns and expenses. When Congress later tried to pass a regulation to fund completion the the fence based on the 2006 mandate, they found the cost of finishing would certainly be more than the Border Patrol’s entire annual budget.

During a 2015 Senate hear on the subject, Ronald Vitiello, deputy cook of border patrol for U.S. Customs and Border Protection, admitted that "It"s a lot more expensive than we expected once we started, and also it was much an ext difficult." because Secure Fences to be passed in 2006, the country has spent $2.3 exchange rate on border fortifications and also fencing.

Trump has at times wavered around the grandiosity and final form of his wall, suggesting that some locations could be extended by fencing and that locations with turbulent terrain i will not ~ need additional fencing beyond preexisting natural barriers. However the baseline estimate of 1,000 mile of a big, beautiful wall made the end of concrete and steel would certainly dwarf any kind of project he, or any other developer, has actually previously undertaken. The New Yorker reported the a 30-foot-tall structure would call for three time the lot of concrete in the Hoover Dam, in addition to 5 exchange rate pounds of stole for reinforcement.

A ar of the border fence in Nogales, Arizona, on the U.S.-Mexico border. Jim Watson/AFP/Getty pictures aside from the cost of materials, consider the limit of the planning process (which the executive order states shall it is in completed in ~ 180 days). The procedure should begin with extensive surveying to figure out how to develop on together vastly different terrain, from dry deserts and also steep mountains to forests and rivers. Specialists interviewed through Smithsonian Magazine think planning alone can take years—certainly much longer than one presidential term.

Engineers have to number out exactly how to anchor slabs the concrete and steel reinforcement in soil and bedrock, consisting of the sulfur-heavy Trans-Pecos soils in southwest Texas that would quickly corrode structure materials. After ~ the order, v its brief analysis period, was signed, science writer Mika McKinnon tweeted: “About that wall: everyone knows that large construction requires extensive geotech investigation & design, yes? earth doesn"t pardon sloppy.”

Once construction—which the DHS has declared will take 2 years—actually starts, the wall has the potential to it is in an environmental disaster. The Institute because that Sustainable Energy and also the environment at university of Bath estimates that 7.8 million metric tons of carbon dioxide will be emitted native concrete alone: the very same volume that emissions released by 823,654 occupied residences over the food of a year.

The wall will additionally cross habitats provided by 111 endangered species, 108 varieties of migratory birds, four wildlife refuges and also fish hatcheries, and a number of protected wetlands, follow to a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Report.

The irony is the at the very least one local group will advantage during the wall’s construction: Mexicans. During the structure process, a good portion of payment may circulation to mexico workers and also construction companies. Jose Garza that the employees Defense Project, a job support organization in Texas, called the New York Times that, because of the demographics the the local construction workforce, “a significant bit” that the workforce will likely be undocumented.

In addition, CEMEX, the Mexican-owned concrete conglomerate, own plants all throughout the border, including U.S.-based subsidiaries, that could bid because that the job. Contractors could opt because that non-local suppliers, however trucking cement and heavy rock long ranges would eventually become cost prohibitive.

Trump, who has approximated in the previous that the wall will price $10 billion to $12 billion, freshly tweeted that when he gets involved in negotiations, "price will certainly come way DOWN!" But couple of of the cost estimates floating about include large line items such together hiring additional border patrol agents or paying for exclusive property.

Some reports suggest the price is already rising: A current Department of countryside Security internal analysis, derived by Reuters, approximates a $21.6 exchange rate price tag for building and construction of the wall. Luxury independent estimates place the expense at approximately $40 billion.

And ever since Press Secretary Sean Spicer backed turn off a proposed setup for a 20 percent border tax, the exact an approach of payment has remained in doubt. Republicans might place resources for the wall in a must-pass spending bill in April, or happen it as part of the 2018 appropriations bill for landscape Security.

A current Wall Street Journal article explored several of the extensive, i have lot of money eminent domain issues involved in obtaining personal property. Years after the certain Fences Act began fence-building en masse, the U.S. Federal government still just owns 100 mile of the 1,254-mile Texas-Mexico border and, as of December 2016, 120 situations involving eminent-domain seizure because that the fence were still tied up in federal court.

None the these approximates factor in the expense of maintenance for such a titanic structure, and also that cost may be among the lasting heritages of the project. The Congressional spending plan Office estimated annual maintenance costs of for sure Fence-style fencing will be roughly 15 percent of construction costs. At that rate, the cost of upkeep method we’ll usually be rebuilding the wall surface every 7 years.

The building and construction of the wall surface presents immense logistical and also financial challenges. And once the built, this physical structure will not only transform the nature of our border, but may prove itself a obstacle to solving the problems it was designed come resolve.

The wall surface as trump has defined it appears to overlook the current state the bilateral relations and also border traffic. Mexico is the unified States’ third-largest trading partner, with $500 exchange rate in items crossing the border every year.

A study compiling data native U.S. Customs and various state travel agencies uncovered that 6 million U.S. Jobs depend ~ above trade v Mexico. Our southern neighbor has additionally proven chin to be pretty cooperative: U.S.-Mexican counternarcotics programs date earlier to the 1930s, and the 2 nations have actually signed 53 contract that address law enforcement alone.

A worn door marks the boundary close to the U.S.-Mexico border in Presidio, Texas. Jim Watson/AFP/Getty images the true the the south Rio Grande valley has end up being a very popular drug-smuggling route, but that’s because smugglers connected with cartels have actually numerous surrounding ports the entry come choose—they"re far an ext likely come use main crossings than to uncover their own. According to testimony by U.S. Customs and also Border protection Commissioner Gil Kerlikowske from last March, “The majority of any type of heroin that we seize is not in between the ports of entry, it’s smuggled with the harbor of entry.”

Forget El Chapo tunnels or drug catapults: many drugs are concealed in passenger vehicles or shipping of legal goods and also sent through official border crossings, Kerlikowske go on to say. One expensive brand-new wall, in effect, just blocks off locations smugglers are least likely to use.

See more: How Many Carbs Does Coors Light Have, 8 Beers You Can Drink On The Keto Diet

How about illegal immigration? The population of human being who have entered the nation illegally peaked in ~ 12.2 million in 2007, just prior to the economy crashed, and also has decreased because then, in large part due to the recession and also its outsized impact on the construction industry.

As border enforcement has end up being increasingly stringent due to the fact that the mid-1980s, follow to an article in the Atlantic, male Mexican migrants have had actually a harder time crossing ago and forth, turning what was when a seasonal flow of labor into much more permanent residents, who, challenged with the growing difficulty of gaining home, increasingly carry their families along.

A popular song, “Juala de Oro” (“Cage that Gold”), provides a perfect metaphor for the difficult choices a mexico migrant has to make. Erecting a permanent wall would pressure more daunting choices.