A medical professional says people can be revived several hours after they have seemingly died. Need to this readjust the means we think around death?

"I understand it must have actually been a Friday approximately lunchtime, since we'd got ago from shopping," the 63-year old says. "I can't remember obtaining out that the car."

Her husband David has actually much fingerprint memories of that day 3 months ago. He opened up the former door of their Wiltshire home and saw Carol lying down, gasping because that breath, the colour swiftly draining from her face.

Carol had had a cardiac arrest - she heart had stopped beating. Luckily, an elderly neighbour knew the rudiments the cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and also quickly started to job-related on her chest.

Paramedics shortly took over, and at a suggest between 30 and 45 minute after she collapse - no-one provided the precise time - Carol's heart began beating again.

You are watching: How long can you be dead and still be revived


"While 45 minute is absolutely remarkable and also a lot of of civilization would have actually written her off, we now recognize there are people who have actually been carried back, three, four, five hours after ~ they've died and have led remarkably good quality lives," claims Dr Sam Parnia, the director of resuscitation study at Stony Brook college in brand-new York.

Most people regard cardiac arrest as associated with death, that says. Yet it is no a final threshold.

Doctors have actually long believed that if who is without a heartbeat for longer than around 20 minutes, the brain usually sick irreparable damage. But this can be avoided, Parnia says, with an excellent quality CPR and careful post-resuscitation care.

He claims it is an important that chest compressions take place at the best rate and force and that patients room not over-ventilated. CPR would certainly be substantially prolonged, with makers doing the work.

As Parnia explains in his new book the Lazarus result (the united state title is Erasing Death), after ~ the brain stops receiving a regular supply of oxygen with the circulation that blood the does not instantly perish but goes into a sort of hibernation, a means of repelling its own process of decay.

The process of "waking up" this hibernated brain may fine be the riskiest time of all, since oxygen have the right to potentially be toxicity at this stage.

The effect, Parnia says, is favor that the a tsunami following an earthquake, and the best an answer is to cool patients down, indigenous 37C come 32C.

"Cooling therapy, the factor it functions so well, is the it in reality slows down mind cell decay," claims Parnia.

After her heart was restarted, she was put on a helicopter whereby a physician cooled she down utilizing the frozen food she had actually just bought at the supermarket.

She was at some point put in the care of Dr Jerry Nolan, an intensive care consultant in ~ Bath's royal United Hospital. This was yet an ext luck - Nolan co-wrote best practice guidelines for the UK Resuscitation Council, which he chairs.

By this time, Carol was in a coma. Together the next few days passed, no one of the signs were good - seizures and also ominous EEG scans suggested that she could be brain dead. The looked like she had actually survived the earthquake but been left ravaged by the tsunami.

On the Monday complying with Carol's collapse, Nolan recommend David and also his daughter Maxine the the kindest thing can be to enable Carol to die. Castle agreed.

But when Maxine saw the hospital again three days later on she discovered her mommy awake and also looking around.

"She stated three little words to me," recalls Maxine. "She said: 'I'm coming home.' It to be a tiny tiny faint whisper."

Cooling treatment is an altering everything. Vice versa, Carol's seizures and low mind activity would once have actually been viewed as unambiguously poor signs, such symptoms might be compatible v a an excellent recovery.

"We're much an ext uncertain 보다 we assumed we were," claims Nolan, adding that study groups across the human being were urgently looking at situations like Carol's to draw up new guidelines.

"Carol was really lucky the she finished up in a hospital with such one eminent expert," he says. "In the US and also the UK there is for sure zero regulation regarding the top quality of treatment that somebody like Carol should receive."

Nolan stops brief of saying that Carol to be brought ago from the dead. Hospitals perform not declare death, that says, until they have ruled the end all procedures that have the right to be reversed. However, he agrees through Parnia the our principle of death needs updating.

"We provided to think fatality was a kind of sudden occasion - we protect against the oxygen going to the brain and after ~ a couple of minutes the was that. However actually, we recognize that the dying process at the to move level goes on for a duration of time."

The progressively blurred line in between life and death is prompting metaphysical questions and also medical ones.

Parnia has end up being fascinated through patients' accounts of being "near death", which that says around 10% the survivors have.

"People from anywhere the human being in essence describe the very same universal experience, yet the interpretation of what they see relies on your own id system," he says.

These descriptions include travelling down tunnels in the direction of bright lights, conference angelic figures, recalling past events and in rarely cases, floating above the operated doctor in the operation theatre.

Parnia is right now working with a number of hospitals top top a job to investigate out of body experiences. One of the components of the study is to ar objects top top high shelves in operating theatres, i beg your pardon are just observable native above.

Caroline Watt is a psychologist in ~ the university of Edinburgh that specialises in examining paranormal accounts v an open but crucial mind. She was the co-author that a review record suggesting the near-death experiences may well it is in based in neurological activity.


Image caption, follow to Parnia, approximately 2% of cardiac survivors recall an suffer of seeing themselves indigenous above

She says one study discovered about half the patients the reported near-death experiences had actually not been anywhere near fatality at all. They had actually experienced them at times when they were expecting a traumatic experience, such as during childbirth. This perhaps argues that whatever the sensation is, that isn't a glimpse the the afterlife.

Ruth Lambert suffered a near-death experience once a loss led come the blood it is provided to her brain being reduced off.

See more: How Many Calories In Coca Cola Life, A Rose By Any Other Name: The Low

"It to be a feeling of welcome and also going come something better," she recalls. "I had a strong sense of gift addressed by God directly, the this was not the appropriate time because that me and also then ns woke up."

Since the time, partly through her work as a an elderly chaplain at an NHS hospital in London, she has been approached number of times with similar accounts.

She remembers one man who came round indigenous his coma terrified - he thought he had actually seen the evil one approaching him and also saying: "You're mine currently - I've obtained you."

She adds the most spiritual people see fatality as a "final gateway" and also that any type of evolution of this ide will it is in very far-ranging for them.

You can listen to Outlook top top the audioeditorfree.com human being Service. Hear to the interview v Sam Parnia and the Brothers family members via iPlayer or browser the documentary podcast archive.