The challenges of Defining and Diagnosing mind Death

A new Johns Hopkins support team help clinicians and also families know a complicated diagnosis.

You are watching: How long can a brain dead person live off life support


A woman lies in a bed in ~ The Johns Hopkins Hospital. Aided by a ventilator, she lungs inflate, deflate, and fill again. Her heart beats and her skin is warm. But her eyes remain closed and she does not react come stimuli such together pain and also light. 

Is she alive or dead?

If you’re unsure, or if the inquiry makes friend uncomfortable, you’re no alone. The hypothetical situation described right here reflects a actual problem: the inherent challenges of diagnosing and also accepting mind death.

The topic was the focus of a September ethics for Lunch conversation in the Chevy Chase bank Auditorium of The Johns Hopkins Hospital, hosted by the Berman academy of Bioethics.

The panel was moderated by anesthesiologist and crucial care professional Robert Stevens, who says the line between life and also death, once plainly perceptible in the type of a beating heart, is now sometimes harder to see since of breakthroughs in lifesaving technologies.

The modern-day intensive care unit can keep a human being with severe brain injuries alive, the says, however may likewise mask evidence that the person has died. The shift from a deep coma to brain death—permanent cessation of all mind function—may not be immediately apparent to an untrained observer. Yet recognizing this shift from life to death is an essential for families, the clinical team and also potential body organ recipients.

When a patient dies, doctors stop treatment and instead emphasis on body organ viability. The body is maintained on life-support machinery if the patient was a registered body organ donor or when the family members makes decisions around organ donation.

To aid clinicians do a brain death diagnosis, The Johns Hopkins Hospital in June 2016 created a determination of death by Neurological Criteria support Team.

Here’s exactly how it works: A patience arrives in the emergency room after an overdose, automobile accident or other trauma that caused extensive brain injury. Medical professionals do everything they deserve to to stabilize the patient, however his mind may have actually suffered irreversible damage.

When attending physicians suspect a patience is brain-dead, they might opt to call a consultant—a Johns Hopkins neurologist, neurosurgeon or an essential care specialist v experience and training in 2 different, yet related, areas: the methods used to identify death, and communicating the nuances of the challenging situation with primary care teams and family members.

The consultant performs a full neurological check to identify if over there are any kind of signs of brain or brainstem function. This contains assessing the journey to take a breath, determining even if it is pupils react to light, and swabbing the earlier of the neck to elicit a gag reflex. The neurological examination must be repeated at the very least once ~ a minimum interval of 6 hours, to ensure that mind function is no temporarily suppressed by factors such as high doses of narcotics or intense cold. 

The support team help those consultants by giving guidance and answering questions. “Our only advantage is experience, due to the fact that we handle more of this cases,” says neurologist and neurocritical care specialist Adrian Puttgen, who creates the group with anesthesiologist and also neurocritical care specialist Adam Schiavi, and also neurologists Rafael Llinas and Brett Morrison. “This team is written right into our hospital policy. We monitor in the background and also come in as essential when yes sir a question.”

Because of the support, brain death determinations take much less time 보다 in the past. “We owe it to the families to solve the question of even if it is a patient is alive or dead as easily as possible,” claims Puttgen. “Otherwise, the a state the limbo.”

A brain death diagnosis is almost always confusing and overwhelming to household members. In a couple of states, though not Maryland, doctors have to accommodate the choices of family members who refuse to accept the diagnosis for spiritual reasons.

See more: How Many Seasons Of The Simpsons Are There To Date, Cast And More

That happened in 2013, as soon as the parental of Jahi McMath relocated the13-year-old indigenous a California hospital come one in brand-new Jersey after a brain death diagnosis following tonsillectomy complications. She body remains attached to life-support machinery.

“Most people have this notion that you’re recognizably alive and then you’re recognizably dead,” says Schiavi. “What’s taken place is the our technological ability to sustain life has moved quicker than our moral capacity to attend to the implications.”

The assistance team is helping. “We space taking energetic steps to readjust the culture, not only for families yet for physicians as well,” that says.