Share all sharing options for: let’s look back at Trump’s actual setup for making Mexico pay because that the wall surface

Trump supporters at a rally in Florida in February 2016. Joe Raedle/Getty photos
Donald trumped didn’t have a lot of of comprehensive plans when he ran for president in 2016, however how Mexico would certainly pay for the border wall surface was actually one of them. He’d choose everybody to go ahead and also forget around that now.

Trump, speaking with reporters top top Thursday on his means to McAllen, Texas, debated his insistence top top a wall at the US-Mexico border that has actually now led to a partial government shutdown lasting nearly three weeks.

You are watching: How is trump making mexico pay for the wall

“When I said Mexico will certainly pay for the wall surface in former of thousands and also thousands the people, clearly they’re no going to compose a check,” he said.

Except it is pretty much what he asserted on the campaign trail. During his 2016 presidential bid, a plan to make Mexico pay for the wall was actually among the few specific points he laid the end — including, essentially, the Mexican government writing a examine for it.

“It’s straightforward decision for Mexico: make a one-time payment of $5-10 billion,” a campaign file titled “Pay for the Wall” from his presidential bid reads.

The president, that is now trying to gain US taxpayers come foot the bill for his border wall, has of late started saying Mexico will pay for the wall indirectly, namely, v the USMCA profession deal to change NAFTA. That’s no going to work, either, yet it’s necessary to keep in mind that Trump had a arrangement for Mexico come pay because that the wall surface directly no so lengthy ago.

Trump definitely had a plan for Mexico to pay because that the wall

Trump has gone on quite a trip on how to acquire his border wall surface built, consisting of his concepts for how Mexico would pay because that it. Yet during the presidential race, the actually had actually some reasonably detailed plans around it — they’re tho on his project website.

The Trump campaign said that it would certainly either require Mexico to make that previously mentioned one-time payment, or it would certainly extract the money indigenous Mexico by blocking remittances come the country and also undertaking other measures.

It would certainly invoke section 326 of the us Patriot plot — the “know her customer” provision that requires financial establishments to know who they’re taking care of in transactions — to worry “detail regulations” under 31 CFR § 130.120-121 that would block remittance payments to Mexico from unauthorized immigrants.

The management would then problem a preeminence that would encompass within the meaning of financial organizations money transfer carriers such as Western Union, encompass wire transfers in the statute’s scope, and require immigrant prove your lawful existence in the US before sending money.

The timeline from there, the project said, was straightforward: Mexico would automatically protest, due to the fact that $24 exchange rate in remittances from mexico nationals in the us go the end each year, and also it would certainly then pay for the wall surface instead of shedding that money.

As’s Dara Lind stated at the moment Trump floated this proposal, mexicans emigrants perform send house a huge amount in remittances. In 2013, it was $22 billion, and also in 2017, that was much more than $26 billion. But, per Lind, “that’s the amount of remittances sent to Mexico period — native legal immigrants, not authorised immigrants, and also even mexico emigrants in nations other 보다 the US.”

So perhaps the trumped campaign’s remittance plan wasn’t totally fleshed out, however even so, the had backup proposals, which girlfriend can also still uncover online:

Mexico must pay for the wall and, till they do, the United says will, amongst other things: impound all remittance payments derived from illegal wages; rise fees top top all short-term visas authorize to mexico CEOs and diplomats (and if vital cancel them); increase fees on all border cross cards – of which us issue about 1 million to mexican nationals yearly (a significant source of visa overstays); boost fees on every NAFTA worker visas from Mexico (another significant source of overstays); and increase fees in ~ ports that entry come the United claims from Mexico . We will not it is in taken benefit of anymore.

As MSNBC’s Katy Tur noted, that wasn’t just the thorough policies either. The implicitly on the campaign trail was always “something basic like cut a check,” she stated on Twitter.

Lots of us pressed consistently in 2016 on how Mexico pays. No clear answer. In late 2015 trump team releases paper saying higher visa fees/fining remittances. The wasn’t precisely feasible or sensible. At rallies, the implicitly was always something an easy like cut a check. Https://

— Katy Tur (

Trump has actually no idea how he’s getting this wall thing done

Trump plainly recognizes the the wall surface is a huge deal for his supporters, and also failing to make progress on it will be a large deal, politically. What that doesn’t understand is how to follow through, at the very least not in ~ the moment.

See more: Game Of Thrones Cast Salary: How Much Do Game Of Thrones Actors Make Per Episode

He’s changed the way he talks about the wall, switching the end the 30-foot concrete wall he talked around on the campaign trail to his existing insistence that he’s yes, really after stole slats. He’s been everywhere the location on how much money he needs for the wall surface and has started to say he could declare a nationwide emergency in order to acquire one, even if it is there’s an actual emergency or not.

The president appears well conscious that American taxpayers space the ones who will salary for any type of current pathways he needs to the wall, and so he’s trying come argue that Mexico will certainly in part convoluted means pay the US ago through trade. Together my colleague Jen Kirby explains, that’s false. The USMCA hasn’t been approved by conference yet, and even if that is, it won’t pay for the wall:

The message of the USMCA doesn’t encompass any particular provisions about a wall surface or capital for any kind of barrier — and also experts say it’s extremely unlikely that if the trade deal is ratified, that will suddenly generate large revenues for the US. And also even if the US economic situation does flourish as a result of the deal, top to more tax revenue, the money will certainly come indigenous American taxpayers — whether consumer or enterprise — and not native Mexico.

Trump’s initial campaign plan for Mexico come pay had problems— together’s Matt Yglesias newly noted, the campaign’s remittance proposal quote the dorn statute, and remittance payment go earlier to mexican residents, no the government. But at the very least there was some type of a plan, also if Trump currently wants to pretend it to be something else.

Will you assistance’s explanatory journalism?

Millions rotate to to understand what’s continue in the news. Ours mission has actually never been more an important than that is in this moment: come empower v understanding. Financial contributions from our readers are a crucial part of sustaining our resource-intensive work-related and assist us save our journalism totally free for all. Please take into consideration making a contribution to today to aid us save our work free for all.